Local
Philadelphia City Council Signals Millions in Annual Support to Reopen Academy of Natural Sciences
A City Council hearing on the Academy of Natural Sciences' sudden closure revealed blame on all sides and a shared push to reopen the nearly 200-year-old museum, with Councilmember Isaiah Thomas saying colleagues could back a couple million dollars a year in recurring city funding.
Philadelphia City Council members said Monday they are prepared to put city money behind efforts to reopen the Academy of Natural Sciences, the nearly 200-year-old museum that closed abruptly in September, after a hours-long hearing that examined how Drexel University and the Academy's own leadership handled the institution's deepening financial troubles.
"I think that today's hearing kind of showed us that there's blame across the board," Councilmember Isaiah Thomas told reporters after the hearing. Supporters in the room applauded when Thomas said the city is ready to help fund the Academy.
"I think a lot of my colleagues will have an appetite for a couple million dollars a year in recurring revenue guaranteed to the Academy," Thomas said.
The Academy has operated as an affiliate of Drexel University since the two organizations partnered in 2011, with the university providing millions of dollars annually to keep the museum running. Last fall, Drexel told the Academy it could no longer afford that support.
In prepared testimony, Drexel President Antonio Merlo said the Academy's operating costs far exceeded its revenue and that deferred maintenance costs, already substantial when the affiliation agreement was signed, continued to climb. He said the museum's historic building on the Benjamin Franklin Parkway requires tens of millions of dollars for deferred maintenance, infrastructure improvements and gallery refurbishment, and that Drexel's Board of Trustees had urged Academy leaders to align spending with revenue without success.
Drexel leadership told the Academy it could either fully merge with the university, giving up control of all its assets including an $80 million endowment, or fully disaffiliate. The Academy had already been exploring other partnerships to address its financial problems, including the possibility of relocating its collection of 19 million scientific specimens to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi.
Drexel and the Academy now agree they should separate, but Academy leaders say financial support is still needed during the transition. Drexel appears unwilling to provide additional funding.
Former employees and supporters welcomed the city's offer to step in. "Hearing city council really just show that they are ready to step up is all I've ever wanted," said Amber Redfield, a former Academy employee who was terminated November 1. "I am ready to reopen the academy right now," she said. "Even though I was terminated November 1st, throw me in tomorrow."
Council members said they want the museum reopened while negotiations over its future continue. Philanthropic organizations, including the William Penn Foundation, have also offered financial help. The foundation plans to fund a study of the most sustainable long-term path for the Academy, but that process is expected to take up to a year.
Thomas said the city cannot afford to wait that long. "Government has to be able to walk at the same time," he said. "No one knows how long a plan is going to take to be created. No one knows how long an economic study is gonna take, but we do know that the more time we take, the more staff gets laid off, the more it's gonna cost us to restart things, to get things opened."
Thomas said he was surprised to learn that discussions about the Academy's financial challenges had been underway behind closed doors since last year without City Council's involvement. "I was very shocked to find out that the conversation had been taking place for so long and no one came to city council," he said. "For us to find out about this in the 11th hour, so late in the game, it just creates a lot of questions."
During the hearing, Suzanne Biemiller, chair of the Academy's Board of Trustees, said the Academy informed the Mayor's office about potential problems in the fall of 2025. That disclosure alarmed council members, who said the Mayor's administration had told them it did not learn of the issues facing the Academy until recently. Biemiller clarified that the initial communication to the Mayor's office did not mention the possibility of the museum closing, but did raise Drexel's request to alter the affiliation agreement because of the financial burden.
A spokesperson for the Mayor's office reiterated that the administration was not alerted last fall that the museum might close, only that there were issues between the Academy and Drexel.
The hearing underscored the stakes for the city: a museum that has anchored the Parkway for generations, a collection of 19 million specimens, and a staff that continues to shrink with each passing week. Council members left little doubt that they see a city role in keeping the institution alive, even as the details of a long-term rescue remain unsettled.