Local
Philadelphia Weighs Waste Contracts as Chester Residents Demand Relief from Incinerator Burden
Philadelphia City Council holds a hearing Wednesday on new waste disposal contracts, with roughly 30% of the city's daily trash headed to a Chester incinerator that residents say has harmed their health and community for decades. Chester advocates and the city's health commissioner are pressing Philadelphia officials to consider environmental justice as they decide where the city's garbage goes for years to come.
Philadelphia City Council is set to hold a hearing Wednesday on the city's next waste disposal contracts, a decision that will shape where Philadelphia's garbage goes for the next four to seven years and that Chester residents say could determine the future of their community.
At the center of the debate is the Reworld waste-to-energy incinerator in Chester, about 20 miles southwest of Philadelphia. Last year, the city sent roughly 180,000 tons of garbage to the facility, and city officials say nearly 30% of Philadelphia's daily waste goes to Chester.
For Zuleen Mayfield, chairperson of Chester Residents Concerned for Quality Living, the consequences of that arrangement have been felt for more than three decades. She said odors and emissions from the facility reach nearby homes and change daily life.
"Immediately it irritates your eyes. It gets in your throat, nose, and you feel it in the pit of your throat," Mayfield said. "You don't want to have people over your house if you're not from the area, because immediately you smell the stench."
Mayfield said the facility has "diminished our community."
Chester has a long history of industrial activity, and residents have repeatedly raised concerns about the cumulative effects of pollution. Dr. Kristen Motley, Chester's health commissioner, said the health challenges facing residents demand attention.
"It is not normal to experience the health impacts that are happening to Chester residents," Motley said. "People are dying in their 30s, in their 40s with small children from diseases like cancer, rare cancer. This is preventable. And if we don't do anything now, we ought to be ashamed of ourselves."
Motley pointed to concerns about cancer, heart disease and kidney disease among Chester residents. She said Philadelphia's upcoming decision on the waste contract presents an opportunity to address longstanding environmental concerns.
"This is an opportunity for Philadelphia to really make a difference in people's lives," she said.
Records from the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection detail a history of environmental violations at the Chester incinerator, with penalties totaling more than $423,000. The records raise questions about the facility's compliance history as Philadelphia considers whether to continue sending garbage there. The violations themselves do not establish a direct connection between the facility's emissions and specific illnesses reported by Chester residents, and available records do not establish that emissions caused those health conditions. Reworld declined to comment on the violations.
Cost is a major factor in the city's decision. Sending garbage to the Chester incinerator remains one of Philadelphia's least expensive disposal options, with a proposed rate of approximately $47 per ton next year.
City officials are also considering a longer-term approach to reduce the amount of waste sent to incinerators and landfills. Councilmember Mark Squilla, who represents Philadelphia's 1st District, has proposed the Zero Waste and Circular Economy Act, which is supported by Mayor Cherelle Parker's administration. The proposal aims to divert 60% of the city's waste from landfills and incinerators by expanding recycling, composting and other alternatives, including converting food and other organic waste into renewable energy.
Squilla argued that reducing Philadelphia's dependence on incinerators will require more than prohibiting the city from sending trash to Chester.
"The bill that we are talking about now that would stop us from sending trash to the incinerator doesn't stop us from sending trash to landfills, and it doesn't even reduce any waste that we are generating here in the city of Philadelphia," Squilla said. "We want to stop sending all trash to landfills and incinerators, but we have to send it somewhere."
Asked what he would say to Chester families who feel their health and quality of life are being sacrificed for Philadelphia, Squilla pointed to the legislation. "The Zero Waste Circular Economy Act gets them to where they want to be," he said.
But building the infrastructure needed to meet those goals could take years, and in the meantime Philadelphia could approve new contracts that continue sending trash to Reworld.
For Mayfield and other advocates, the debate is about environmental justice and whether residents of one community should continue bearing the environmental burden of another city's waste. Chester residents do not vote in Philadelphia's municipal elections, but decisions by Philadelphia officials directly affect their community.
After more than 30 years of organizing, Mayfield said she is no longer interested in simply hoping for a different outcome.
"Well, we are not going to hope. We are going to work for it," she said. "Our intention is to convince the councilmembers of Philadelphia to do the right damn thing."
For Philadelphia, Wednesday's hearing is about the future of its trash. For Mayfield and her neighbors in Chester, it is about the future of their community and the air they breathe.