Local
Philadelphia City Council Grills Human Services Chief Over Foster Care Failures After 10-Year-Old's Killing
Council members demanded answers from Commissioner Kimberly Ali after Malayshia Allford, a 10-year-old foster child, was found beaten to death, with officials acknowledging a registry loophole let her foster parent take her in despite a prior abuse allegation. Ali declined to discuss specifics of the case, drawing sharp rebukes from lawmakers who called the death preventable.
PHILADELPHIA â City Council members pressed Philadelphia's top human services official Thursday over how a 10-year-old foster child ended up in a home she should never have been placed in, a case that has exposed gaps in the child welfare system and prompted calls for sweeping reform.
Commissioner of Human Services Kimberly Ali opened the hearing by asking those in the room to remember Malayshia Allford, the 10-year-old found beaten to death earlier this month. Ali said plainly that the child's life mattered and that every child harmed by the system meant to protect them mattered too â then told Council she could not discuss the specifics of the case.
That answer did not sit well with Councilmember Cindy Bass.
"This was preventable. This death was preventable," Bass told Ali. "There was so many red flags all over the place that it was really a failure on a colossal scale. Everything failed."
Ali said a loophole in the system allowed Carprice Williams, Allford's foster parent, to care for the child even though she should not have been looking after foster children. Williams has been charged with murder in Allford's death after the 10-year-old was found dead in a car parked in Lindenwold, New Jersey.
According to Ali, Williams had a prior abuse allegation expunged from her record, and the department did not have access to that information. Ali pointed to the state Department of Human Services' resource family registry as the place where she believes the gap can be closed.
Bass rejected that framing. "Everyone is expecting that everyone who almost kills a foster child doesn't get to be a foster parent again," she said.
Councilmember Jim Harrity asked Ali what needed to change to prevent future tragedies. "How do we fix this system?" he asked. "What are you going to do to make sure that no more of our children end up in the grave?"
The hearing grew emotional when Councilmember Katherine Gilmore Richardson, who was adopted as a child, dabbed away tears with a tissue as she described how deeply the death affected her. The system worked for her, she said, but it does not work for everyone.
Gilmore Richardson also asked why the foster system is concentrated in certain city neighborhoods. Ali said the department tries to keep children in the neighborhoods of their birth parents.
Nonprofit Community Umbrella Agencies receive roughly $8 million to $13 million each per year to manage foster care in the city, Ali said. Social workers are typically assigned 10 children each â about one third of the state's maximum caseload of 30 â a lower ratio Ali said the department maintains to keep better oversight of families.
Councilmember Jamie Gauthier said Allford's murder was the worst possible outcome but noted other problems in the foster care system, including the number of people experiencing homelessness who have aged out of care. She asked how much money is set aside for family reunification, citing the fact that Allford had been in two foster homes in four years.
About 1,700 children receive services in their homes through the child welfare system, Ali said, with the city spending roughly $190 million a year to keep young people with their families whenever possible. Of that, about $5 million pays for things such as rental assistance and food to keep families together and stable.
Gauthier said that funding is "too low" and needs to be expanded.
Councilmember Nina Ahmad said the city has "very far to go and we have to reimagine the system," calling for more support to move the work forward. Other council members called for additional city financing to address the problems in Ali's department.
The hearing comes as the city grapples with the fallout from Allford's death and questions about how a foster parent with a prior abuse allegation was able to take in a child. Council members made clear that the answers provided Thursday were not enough, and that the pressure for change will continue.