Local
Tony & Nick's Steaks to Close Friday After 35 Years, Citing Financial and Tax Troubles
The South Philadelphia cheesesteak shop formerly known as Tony Luke's will shut its doors for good on Friday, owners announced on Instagram, citing financial difficulties and tax problems. The closure follows the 2024 federal tax fraud sentencing of its owners.
Tony & Nick's Steaks, a fixture of South Philadelphia's cheesesteak scene for 35 years, will close permanently on Friday, its owners announced this week in a letter posted to the shop's Instagram story.
"After 35 years in businessâand even more years spent serving sandwiches togetherâthis is one of the hardest things we have ever had to say," the letter reads. "Financial difficulties and tax problems have brought us to a point where we can no longer keep our doors open. It breaks my heart to write these words. We are devastated."
The shop, owned by Anthony Lucidonio Sr. and his son Nicholas Lucidonio, operated for decades under the name Tony Luke's before rebranding in 2022 amid a family feud and mounting tax troubles. The name change followed a split between Lucidonio Sr. and his other son, Tony Luke Jr., who departed the business in 2015 and now owns Tony Luke's franchise locations in multiple states. According to the franchise's website, it has no connection to Tony & Nick's.
The closure comes two years after both Lucidonio Sr. and Nicholas Lucidonio were sentenced to 20 months in federal prison. The pair had pleaded guilty in a tax fraud case in which they concealed nearly $8 million in sales over a decade, paying employees partly off the books and maintaining separate ledgers to hide revenue from the IRS.
In their farewell message, the owners expressed gratitude to the community that supported the business for generations. "We wish this chapter had a different ending," the letter says. "Please know how grateful we are for the years you gave us and for allowing our family to be part of your lives."
While the retail storefront is closing, Tony & Nick's Catering will continue to operate, according to the letter.
The closure marks the end of an era for a family name long synonymous with Philadelphia's signature sandwich, and a cautionary tale about the pressures facing small businessesâand the consequences when financial strain leads to cutting corners.