Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Local

Federal Lawsuit Challenges Philadelphia's No-Stopping Bike Lane Rule on Spruce and Pine Under ADA

A new federal lawsuit argues that Philadelphia's 2024 ban on stopping in the Spruce and Pine street bike lanes violates the Americans with Disabilities Act by making it impossible for some disabled residents to get in and out of vehicles. The city says it won't comment on active litigation, while bike advocates call the suit a pretext to reclaim parking.

Federal Lawsuit Challenges Philadelphia's No-Stopping Bike Lane Rule on Spruce and Pine Under ADA

A federal lawsuit filed in Philadelphia argues that the city's 2024 ordinance banning vehicles from stopping in the Spruce and Pine street bike lanes violates the Americans with Disabilities Act, setting up a new legal fight over street safety and accessibility in Center City and Society Hill.

The ordinance, passed by City Council in 2024, changed the protected bike lanes on Spruce and Pine from "No Parking" to "No Stopping" zones, eliminating a 20-minute grace period that had allowed drivers to legally stop in the lanes. The lawsuit contends that the stricter rule leaves residents with mobility disabilities unable to access curbside pickups and drop-offs.

Carl Roeder, a Pine Street resident of 11 years and one of two plaintiffs in the case, said walking any distance has become difficult. "It's very difficult for me to walk any distance at all. I walk with a cane," Roeder said. He described having to step into the roadway to enter a vehicle as hazardous, and said a concrete curb installed to protect the bike lane would make matters worse.

George Bochetto, the attorney representing the plaintiffs, framed the case as a matter of federal civil rights. "The federal law says when you have disabled people, you must make reasonable accommodations so they can function in society," Bochetto said.

The lawsuit asks a judge to order the city to adopt a disability exception to the no-stopping ban. The city has 30 days to respond. A city spokesperson said officials do not comment on active litigation.

The case has drawn sharp pushback from Philly Bike Action, which has spent years advocating for safer bike infrastructure. In a statement, the group called the class action "an underhanded use of the legal process that purports to act on behalf of the broader disability community," noting that disability advocates and AARP have long highlighted the safety benefits bike lanes provide to disabled and older residents. The group said the suit is "nothing more than an attempt by a privileged group of neighbors to keep their parking spots," and pointed out that the city had provided accessible curbside access through additional loading zones that were later removed after another legal challenge.

Philly Bike Action celebrated when the city installed loading zones on Spruce and Pine two years ago, giving neighbors a legal place to load and unload instead of blocking the bike lanes. Those loading zones were uninstalled amid two other lawsuits challenging the city's bike lane safety upgrades.

Roeder said loading zones are not a workable solution because he cannot walk to the end of the block, and because a zone offers little help if another vehicle is already using it.

Jessie Amadio, an organizer with Philly Bike Action, said the underlying conflict is straightforward. "There's no compromise with a car being in a bike lane. It just defeats the purpose and makes it unusable and unsafe," Amadio said.

The dispute arrives as Philadelphia continues to wrestle with how to balance street safety, accessibility and parking in dense neighborhoods, and as multiple lawsuits test the future of the Spruce and Pine bike lane upgrades.

More from The Philadelphia Focal