Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Milwaukee Focal

Milwaukee's independent voice

Local

West Allis Man Charged With First-Degree Homicide in Wife's 2024 Basement Staircase Death

Benjamin A. Carpenter, 45, was arrested Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the October 2024 death of his wife, Erica, after investigators found opioids and sleep aid in her system and alarming Google searches on his phone.

West Allis Man Charged With First-Degree Homicide in Wife's 2024 Basement Staircase Death

WEST ALLIS, Wis. — A 45-year-old West Allis man has been charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the death of his wife, who was found at the bottom of a basement staircase in October 2024 in what was initially reported as a fall.

Benjamin A. Carpenter was taken into custody early Tuesday morning, according to West Allis police. The Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office filed the charge the same day, following an investigation that spanned more than two years.

The case began on the night of Oct. 13, 2024, when officers were dispatched around 10:38 p.m. for a welfare check at a home in the 2900 block of South 95th Street. A caller reported that an adult woman, Erica A. Carpenter, had fallen and was bleeding from the head.

When officers arrived, they found Benjamin Carpenter performing CPR on his wife at the bottom of the basement stairs. Officers took over CPR until West Allis Fire Department personnel arrived. Erica Carpenter was transported to a local hospital, where she was pronounced dead at approximately 5:14 a.m. on Oct. 14, 2024.

According to a 17-page criminal complaint, Benjamin Carpenter told investigators that his wife collapsed while they were doing laundry in the basement and that he slipped while carrying her upstairs, causing them both to fall.

But the medical examiner's findings contradicted that account, according to the complaint. Investigators said Erica Carpenter's system contained unexplained opioids and a high amount of sleep aid, and that she had sustained blunt force trauma to her neck.

The complaint also details evidence that investigators say points to a planned killing. Police found that Carpenter had been intimate with another woman before his wife's death; the woman told investigators she did not want to date him until he got a divorce, according to the complaint.

Additionally, police uncovered what the complaint describes as alarming Google searches on Carpenter's phone. The weekend of his wife's death, his search history included the query "can I crush pills and take them in water," according to the complaint.

Text messages from Erica Carpenter to her husband also raised concerns. About a month before her death, she wrote, "And what the (expletive) have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?" When he replied, "Your water???" she responded, "Yes, my water. There's been powdery (expletive) in it at least twice now."

When a reporter visited Carpenter's home Tuesday, someone else answered the door and said Carpenter was not there and that they did not know his whereabouts. Police said he had already been arrested earlier that morning.

The investigation into Erica Carpenter's death remains ongoing. Anyone with information is asked to contact the West Allis Police Department at 414-302-8000.

The charge marks a significant development in a case that had remained open for two years, and it raises questions about how a death initially treated as an accidental fall was ultimately investigated as a homicide. For a community that has waited for answers, the filing represents the first formal step toward accountability.

More from The Milwaukee Focal