Local
MPS Wraps Up Great Schools Committee Meetings Without Closure List, Residents Push for Building Repairs Over Closures
Milwaukee Public Schools concluded its Great Schools Committee meetings Monday with no final school closure list, as residents overwhelmingly favored repairing and expanding aging buildings over closing or merging schools. The district will now post all feedback online and open a 30-day public comment period.
Milwaukee Public Schools has not yet decided which schools it will close or finalized other plans to address declining enrollment and its budget deficit, despite wrapping up the final scheduled meeting of its Great Schools Committee on Monday.
At the meeting, held in the North Division High School cafeteria, community members reviewed a wide range of ideas proposed by administration, staff and residents since the committee began meeting in September. The district displayed suggestions for each of the eight school board districts on walls around the room, and attendees marked their favorites with blue dots and their least favorites with red dots.
Superintendent Brenda Cassellius created the Great Schools Committee to help establish criteria for potential school closures. She said the district will review all the feedback, post it online alongside the Budget Advisory Committee's budget priorities, and open public comment for 30 days. Cassellius also said the district will conduct specialized outreach at affected schools, responding to calls from the Milwaukee Inner-City Congregations Allied for Hope's Education Task Force to ensure all communities receive adequate notice and discussion about closures, mergers and investments.
The most popular ideas focused on repairing or replacing aging buildings. A building addition at Rufus King High School drew the most support of any single proposal. Angela Harris, an MPS educator and parent of a Rufus King student, said the school needs an updated athletic field and equipment.
At Siefert School, built in 1903, attendees backed adding a new HVAC system and elevators. Principal Deirdre Lafford had suggested at a Nov. 9 meeting rebuilding the school on its playground site while students continue learning in the old building.
Fifteen people supported rebuilding Lincoln Avenue School to serve more than just its own students. MPS is in discussions about potentially rebuilding the school, which was destroyed in a June fire and is slated for demolition in the coming months.
Community members from District 4 on the North Side pushed for a new building behind Auer Avenue School, even though planning firm Perkins Eastman included the school in January among its recommendations of five schools to close. A suggestion to add 3-year-old kindergarten classes and seventh and eighth grade at Auer received 12 blue dots and five red dots.
Suggestions to close or merge schools drew the most disagreement. Closing Riley Dual Language Montessori School and moving its dual language program elsewhere was among the least popular ideas, with 19 red dots. Nine participants opposed closing the 10 smallest schools in the district, while two supported it. Seven opposed merging Carver Academy and Cass Street School.
A dozen people opposed a sweeping merger proposal that would move Milwaukee School of Languages into the Marshall High School building, merge Marshall into Obama School, Vincent High School and James Madison High School, merge Kilbourn School into Kluge Elementary School, and merge Hampton School into Lancaster School.
Several closure ideas in District 3 were also shared for feedback: Franklin School, under capacity by almost 300 students; LaFollette School, under capacity by more than 200 students with only 14% of students living in the area; Sherman Multicultural Arts School, under capacity by more than 500 students with $2 million in deferred maintenance costs; and Townsend Street School, which has declining enrollment and over $5 million in deferred maintenance. One attendee wrote that they would agree to closures only if they are spread out over 10 years and accompanied by new buildings.
Participants also expressed strong demand for expanding the district's Montessori program, which MPS says is the largest cluster of public Montessori schools in the country. One participant noted that most Montessori schools are full and said the district should create more seats. Three people supported turning Pratt Elementary School into a Montessori school. Another participant cautioned that any expansion must be done carefully because Montessori teachers require specialized training and principals should also be specialized in Montessori learning.
Throughout the committee meetings, attendees like Joshua Taylor, an MPS paraprofessional and organizer with the Milwaukee Party for Socialism and Liberation, have called for expanding the district's Community School Program. "Expanding the Community School Program, strengthening our community support, sustaining school cultures," Taylor said in October. "Closing schools, especially in District 4, doesn't do any of those things."
Attendees also called for greater development of the Community School Program at Hopkins Lloyd Community School, another school originally on Perkins Eastman's suggested closure list, and at Auer Avenue School. Several supported creating a system of community schools to serve students with adverse childhood experiences.
Across districts, people called for a shuttle system to help neighborhood students who face long walks to school. At the Nov. 9 meeting, participants said requiring students to walk a mile to school is a barrier. One suggested a shuttle leaving every 15 minutes; another proposed shuttling children who live farther than three blocks from school.
Several participants also want the district to end its K-8 model or create more middle schools. Seven people supported changing Obama, which currently serves 5-year-old kindergarten through 12th grade, to serve only high school or only 3-year-old kindergarten through sixth grade, while two left red dots. One person noted that the K-8 environment is "not appropriate for 11 and 12 year olds or the 3-year-olds." Another note read: "Stop pushing sixth graders back into elementary schools. We deserve middle schools."