Local
Milwaukee's Lead Pipe Replacement Prioritizes Disadvantaged Neighborhoods Using UW-Madison Health Index
Milwaukee Water Works is using a University of Wisconsin-Madison tool originally designed to measure neighborhood disadvantage to decide which lead service lines to replace first, as the city races to remove more than 55,000 remaining lead pipes by a 2037 EPA deadline.
Milwaukee is leaning on an unlikely tool to guide its race to remove tens of thousands of lead water pipes by a 2037 federal deadline: a neighborhood disadvantage index developed by University of Wisconsin-Madison researchers to study health disparities.
At the end of 2025, Milwaukee Water Works still had more than 55,000 residential properties with lead service lines on the utility-owned side, the customer-owned side or both, according to the utility. It had not yet identified the pipe materials serving another 27,000 properties.
The city cannot replace every line at once, and lead exposure risks are not spread evenly across neighborhoods. Most homes known to have lead lines are clustered in older neighborhoods around downtown, while properties with service lines of unknown material tend to be farther out.
To decide where work will do the most good, Milwaukee Water Works assigns each property a priority score. Seventy percent of that score comes from the Area Deprivation Index, or ADI, a measure of relative socioeconomic disadvantage developed by UW-Madison researchers. Another 25 percent comes from the share of local children who tested positive for lead poisoning, and 5 percent from the density of lead service lines in the area. The city updates the scores every other year.
"We needed to expand the lead service line replacement program, and we needed to develop a, for lack of a better word, defensible method to expand that program," said Patrick Pauly, superintendent of Milwaukee Water Works.
The weighting reflects research showing that economically disadvantaged communities often face compounded lead risks because they tend to have older housing and sit near former industrial sites. The ADI, built from 17 U.S. Census American Community Survey measures covering income, education, housing and employment, ranks small census block groups on a national percentile scale from 1 to 100 and a statewide decile scale from 1 to 10, with higher numbers indicating greater disadvantage.
Dr. Amy Kind, a professor of geriatrics and gerontology at UW-Madison and founding director of its Center for Health Disparities Research, led the 2014 effort to update and refine the index using modern census data. She said the measure is not necessarily the underlying cause of risk but is a strong signal of it.
"It may not be the thing that ultimately drives the risk," Kind said. "But it has been an extremely strong marker that something going on in that area is increasing risk, whatever it might be."
Kind said she and her colleagues originally expected the index to be used mainly by health systems and researchers. Instead, community groups and local governments have adopted it widely. The university has tracked more than 3,500 academic papers citing the index and more than 400 uses across different fields, including a study linking environmental factors to Alzheimer's disease risk and a Puerto Rico effort to target mosquito-borne dengue fever. Kind launched the Neighborhood Atlas in 2018 to make the data easier to access.
Milwaukee's lead problem dates to 1872, when the city required lead service lines. The mandate was repealed in 1962, but older pipes remained in many residential buildings. The city has replaced nearly 15,000 lines since broadening its efforts in 2017, Pauly said. Federal funding from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law allowed the utility to accelerate from about 1,000 replacements a year to 5,000.
A priority program launched in 2024, focused on equity, offers free replacements to eligible residents. More than 6,000 properties have been completed under that program, concentrated largely on the North Side but expanding into near South Side neighborhoods. Pauly expects the utility to reach 20,000 total lead lines replaced next year.
A major question looms once federal infrastructure funding runs out in 2028. Pauly said one option is returning to a system that required homeowners to pay part of the cost of replacing the privately owned portion of their service lines.
"I don't believe the city has the financial capacity to take on fully funding the private side replacement costs," he said. That prospect could complicate a program built around prioritizing neighborhoods where residents already face financial hardship.
For residents whose lines are not yet scheduled for replacement, free tap water testing is available through programs such as the one run by Julie LaRose, lead and nutrition program coordinator at the MacCanon Brown Homeless Sanctuary. LaRose said she recognizes residents' concerns but emphasized that Milwaukee's water is highly regulated and that no sample tested through her program has exceeded one part per billion of lead, far below the federal limits for bottled water and the EPA's action threshold for utilities.
"If you're nervous about this, let's test it," LaRose said.