Local
Federal appeals court weighs whether Milwaukee Tool can be sued over Chinese prison labor
A former prisoner who says he was forced to stitch Milwaukee Tool-branded gloves in a Chinese prison is asking the 7th Circuit to revive his lawsuit against the Brookfield company. The ruling could decide whether U.S. firms can be held liable for profiting from forced labor abroad.
A federal appeals court is weighing whether Brookfield-based Milwaukee Electric Tool Corp. can be held liable for allegedly benefiting from forced prison labor in China, in a case that could reshape how U.S. companies are held accountable for abuses deep in their supply chains.
The plaintiff, identified in court records as Xu Lun because he fears for his safety, says he and other prisoners at Chishan Prison in China's central Hunan Province were forced to manufacture Milwaukee Tool-branded work gloves for a supplier, Shanghai Select Safety Products. According to a 2023 filing in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin, Xu said workers were paid between $1.41 and $42.50 per month.
Xu is appealing a December ruling by U.S. District Judge Brett H. Ludwig, who dismissed the case. Ludwig found the court lacked jurisdiction over Milwaukee Tool's Hong Kong-based parent company, Techtronic Industries, and concluded that Congress had not given a "clear, affirmative indication" that the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act applies outside the United States.
The 7th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal against Techtronic but allowed the case against Milwaukee Tool to proceed. Oral arguments were held Nov. 4.
The lawsuit alleges Milwaukee Tool and Techtronic violated a provision of the federal trafficking law that lets victims sue anyone who knowingly benefits from their forced labor. Milwaukee Tool has denied the allegations, telling Wisconsin Watch it has "found no evidence to support the claims being made" about its supply chain.
The case has drawn attention from human rights advocates who say the outcome could affect workers around the world.
"It's really important for victims of trafficking abroad to be able to bring claims in the United States when someone who benefited from that trafficking is based here, and that's the question before the court," said Charity Ryerson, a human rights lawyer and executive director of the Chicago-based Corporate Accountability Lab.
At oral arguments, plaintiff's attorney Jennifer Bennett argued the law applies because Milwaukee Tool is an American company that profited from forced labor through U.S. sales.
"It's benefiting in the United States from sales in the United States to United States customers. That's exactly the conduct that this statute was designed to prohibit," Bennett said.
Attorney David Horniak, representing Milwaukee Tool, argued the company did not participate in the forced labor venture. "The only things that Milwaukee Tool is alleged to have done in the U.S. is order these gloves, buy these gloves, and sell them in the U.S.," he said.
Horniak warned that holding Milwaukee Tool liable could have sweeping consequences, suggesting that "every consumer who buys goods on Amazon or Temu, in theory, potentially benefits from forced labor, maybe unwittingly." He also argued that the Chinese government, not a private company, forced prisoners to work.
Bennett countered that government involvement is precisely why the law is needed. Congress, she said, was concerned that foreign governments were not doing enough to stop trafficking and might in some cases be participating in it.
"The whole reason this provision was enacted is because Congress thought it wasn't enough to just prohibit forced labor. What it had to do is undermine the market," Bennett said. "The purpose of (this law) is to ensure that American companies are not unfairly undercutting their competitors, unfairly taking jobs away from American workers, and creating a market for forced labor by selling goods in the United States that are made with forced labor."
The allegations first surfaced in a 2023 Wisconsin Watch investigation that detailed accounts from Taiwanese human rights activist Lee Ming-che, who spent nearly five years at Chishan Prison after a 2017 conviction for "subverting state power." Lee said he and hundreds of other prisoners were forced to work about 13 hours a day, seven days a week, for the equivalent of about 48 cents a day.
After the reporting, Walmart pulled the gloves from its marketplace, and U.S. Customs and Border Protection in April 2024 blocked imports of the gloves under Section 307 of the 1930 tariff law, which prohibits goods made with forced labor from entering the country. The agency cited information that "reasonably indicates the use of convict labor" at Shanghai Select and two subsidiaries.
Ryerson said a ruling against the plaintiff could prevent workers who have suffered abuses from bringing similar claims in Wisconsin, Illinois and Indiana. A win, she said, would help ensure forced labor remains a risky proposition for American businesses.
"Incarcerating people and forcing them to labor is really profitable," Ryerson said. "If you make a lot of money off of that, then that creates problematic political incentives to incarcerate more people."
Even an unsuccessful appeal could have an impact, said Nicholas Bequelin, a senior fellow at Yale Law School's Paul Tsai China Center and a former Asia-Pacific regional director at Amnesty International.
"There is no doubt that forced labor practices are endemic to prison labor in China, and that some of the products that are the result of prison labor make their way to the United States market," Bequelin said in an email. "American consumers are mostly left in the dark about this, even though importing such products is illegal under U.S. law, and raising awareness through litigation in the U.S. is an important part of the effort to curb forced labor in China."
The 7th Circuit has not indicated when it will rule.