Local
Wisconsin Treatment Courts Graduate 54% as Report Urges Less Punitive Approach
A new Wisconsin Policy Forum report finds just over half of participants in state-funded treatment courts graduate, with stark racial disparities and widespread use of jail sanctions. Advocates are calling for deferred prosecution and expanded medication-assisted treatment.
MADISON â Just 54% of participants in Wisconsin treatment courts funded through the state's Treatment Alternatives and Diversion program graduated between 2019 and 2024, according to a new report from the Wisconsin Policy Forum that examines the state's 104 treatment courts and recommends reducing punitive responses to addiction.
The report, commissioned by the global health nonprofit Vital Strategies, drew on data from 61 TAD-funded courts, surveys of 53 treatment court coordinators across 43 counties, and court manuals and websites. It was released at a Tuesday press conference where authors and practitioners discussed the findings.
Treatment courts â also known as drug courts, wellness courts, veterans courts and OWI courts â offer people facing criminal charges related to substance use a path to avoid conviction or receive leniency if they complete treatment and supervision requirements.
"It's worth noting that sometimes there's a misconception that treatment court is easy or that it doesn't ask a lot of participants," said Jason Stein, president of the Wisconsin Policy Forum. "The data tell a different story in terms of who makes it through to the end."
Stein said the national graduation rate is higher, at 60.7%, according to the National Treatment Court Resource Center.
Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Carl Ashley pushed back on the idea that treatment court is a lenient alternative. "Treatment court is the hardest thing participants have ever done," he said. "They appear regularly before a judge. They are drug tested. They attend treatment. They must be honest, and when they fall short, they have to recognize that. What they also get for the first time in their lives is a team that believes they can change."
The report also documented significant racial disparities. Among people referred to TAD treatment courts, 82% are white, compared with 7.6% Black and 6.9% Native American. As participants move through eligibility, admission and graduation, the white share grows while the shares of Black and Native American participants decline.
"These disparate outcomes make this an important area for policymakers, treatment court teams and the general public to keep track of," Stein said.
Jail remains a common sanction. Sixty of the 61 TAD courts reported using jail as a sanction, such as when a participant is re-arrested or reuses substances. Most court officials said they do not use jail in response to a positive drug test alone, but 10 of 45 respondents â about one-fifth â did use short-term jail sanctions in that circumstance.
Stein noted that people released from jail face a heightened risk of overdose, and said the state's treatment court community could benefit from a broader discussion about when incarceration is appropriate. National best-practice standards emphasize jail as a tool for public safety rather than a response to substance use, he said.
Adrienne Hurst of Vital Strategies offered several recommendations based on the findings. She said punishment for drug use is not treatment and urged courts to avoid "punitive systems that punish predictable setbacks." More than 20% of reviewed court manuals report using jail-based sanctions after a positive urine test, and 29% of survey responses cited recurring use as a reason to terminate participation â which, she said, "means return to jail."
Hurst also recommended deferring prosecution rather than requiring a conviction or guilty plea for eligibility, which she said could reduce the collateral consequences of a criminal record that make recovery harder. She cautioned against overly rigid regulations that could reduce access and increase punitive responses, and urged courts to allow all FDA-approved medications for opioid use disorder, including methadone and buprenorphine, which she said are more protective against overdose than naltrexone.
She further recommended that courts review fines and fees so they do not become barriers to participation, and consider accepting people at high risk of recidivism, who research shows may benefit most from intensive programs. Hurst noted that 41% of survey respondents said their courts exclude people who sell drugs, even though low-level sales are often a form of survival for people with substance use disorder.
Eli Corbin, harm reduction coordinator for the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, said at the press conference that treatment court helped him turn his life around because his relationship with the judge, district attorney and other key players shifted from punitive to supportive, providing accountability and community.
Judge Ashley said treatment courts reduce recidivism by as much as 58% and save up to $6,000 per person through fewer arrests, court cases and days in jail. "That is money we can return to the community," he said, "but the real savings are harder to count: the crime that never happens; the overdose call that never comes; the child who never enters foster care."
Drug and narcotics violations accounted for nearly 25% of arrests in Wisconsin in 2023, according to the report, underscoring the stakes for a court system that serves as one of the state's primary responses to addiction.