Local
Madison police solve fewer than half of thefts, stolen cars; new specialized teams show mixed results
Madison Police Chief John Patterson says a shift to specialized investigative teams is improving some clearance rates, but staffing limits and strained community trust leave many property crimes unsolved.
Madison police have consistently solved fewer than half of reported thefts and stolen vehicles over the past decade, even as the department has moved to a new team-based investigative model that officials say is beginning to show results for some crimes.
According to a review of Wisconsin Department of Justice crime-solving data, the Madison Police Department's clearance rates for property crimes remain low, with fewer than one in five stolen car and theft cases typically solved. Homicide and assault cases fare better, with solve rates hovering near 80% or higher.
Police Chief John Patterson, who has led the department for less than two years after nearly three decades with the agency, defended his officers' work but acknowledged room for improvement.
"I think we're exceptional not just because of the work that we're producing and the service we're delivering, but it's because we recognize we can always do better and are constantly trying to improve," Patterson said.
The department fully transitioned last year to specialized investigative teams, where detectives focus on specific crime types such as homicides, burglaries or sexual assaults, rather than investigating cases geographically by police district. Patterson pointed to burglary clearance rates as evidence the model is working: those rates were consistently below 10% until 2022, then climbed to 24% last year.
"It's allowed us to get a better understanding of what's happening in the city, how to address it, and maybe come up with some different ways of going about dealing with them," said Detective Lt. Glenn Davis, who oversees a team of 12 detectives and two sergeants investigating homicides and attempted homicides.
Rape cases have also seen improvement, with the solve rate rising from 28% in 2014 to as high as 63% a decade later, though it settled near 40% last year. Patterson attributed the increase partly to cultural shifts that have made survivors more comfortable reporting to law enforcement, along with collaboration with support organizations like the RCC Sexual Violence Resource Center.
Dana Pellebon, who runs the RCC center, said specialized teams make a real difference because investigators who handle sexual assault cases regularly become inherently better at them. The center trains local law enforcement on trauma-informed interview practices and evidence collection.
Staffing remains the biggest hurdle, particularly for high-volume property crimes. Patterson said about 300 officers are assigned to patrol and traffic enforcement, while only 67 of the department's sworn officers are detectives. Each detective typically handles 45 to 50 cases annually, according to Assistant Chief Angie Kamoske.
Last year, the property crime unit had nearly 400 burglaries to investigate. "Sometimes it's a significant hurdle to follow every case as far as possible when you have 400 of them that require your attention," Patterson said.
The department has a $103 million annual budget and nearly 600 employees, making it the most-funded city agency. Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway asked agencies this year to identify about 2% in cuts for next year, which would amount to roughly $2 million for police. Her executive budget largely maintained staffing, adding two positions for body-worn camera implementation, and the City Council unanimously approved it Nov. 10.
Community trust has grown more strained since a Madison officer shot and killed Corey Ruiz, a 38-year-old Black man, in July. The shooting remains under investigation by state authorities. Ruiz was killed at the intersection of Williamson and South Baldwin streets after officers responded to a report of someone checking parked cars. A struggle ensued, and investigators say Ruiz pulled a knife, injuring an officer, before another officer shot him.
Aeiramique Glass, the city's former independent police monitor who was fired by the City Council in October, said the shooting and its aftermath highlighted practices that have led to a "complete breakdown in trust" between the department and the community.
"Without our community trust, I mean our public safety crumbles, frankly," Patterson said. "When you have incidents that strain your trust, it can affect how people choose to interact with you."
Glass also questioned how the department allocates resources, noting that more than 60% of Madison arrests last year were for less serious offenses like disorderly conduct and driving under the influenceâcrimes for which the FBI does not track clearance rates. She pointed to a reported stabbing on Williamson Street in October, where the victim was arrested while the assailant remained at large, as an example of how distrust can affect cooperation with police.
"It's important to look at, is your proactive policing causing more harm than it is reducing crimes from happening in the first place?" Glass said. "And if not, restructure so that most of what you all are focusing on is solving the crimes that are taking place, because this doesn't make sense to have it be below 50% in any of these areas."
Former Police Chief Noble Wray, who led the department from 2004 to 2013, said community relationships are essential to solving crimes. "Do I trust the police? Do I believe that they have the character? That they're a good department, and that they know their policies, procedure and law?" Wray said, describing concerns some residents may have.
The department announced in September it will create a new Service Excellence and Outreach Section next year focused on use of force, professional development, accountability and transparency.