Local
Adams-Friendship School District to absorb $63K loss after email scam; business manager resigns
A vendor impersonation scheme redirected a $92,180 payment meant for classroom relocation, and the district now expects to recover only about $29,000 after insurance and bank clawbacks.
ADAMS, Wis. â The Adams-Friendship School District is set to absorb an unrecovered loss of $63,128.53 after a scammer impersonated a vendor and redirected a six-figure payment, district officials said.
The trouble began on June 27, when the district received a $92,180 invoice from Cary Specialized Services for hauling relocatable classrooms from Illinois to Adams-Friendship High School. A business manager asked for electronic payment details by email, but a third party posing as the vendor replied with banking information that looked legitimate, according to the district.
The district entered those details into its Skyward financial system and processed a payment on July 27. The district's bank flagged and returned that transaction.
Rather than pause and verify, the business manager kept communicating through the same email thread. The impersonator then supplied revised instructions pointing to a different fraudulent account attributed to Sendo Group LLC. On Aug. 3, a payment was processed without contacting the real vendor, consulting the rest of the administration team or independently confirming the account information.
The legitimate vendor reached out on Aug. 19 after not being paid, and that is when the district discovered the money had gone to a fraudulent recipient.
The district alerted its bank, reported the scam to the City of Adams Police Department and brought in technology staff, legal counsel and its insurers. The business manager was placed on administrative leave on Oct. 16 and submitted his resignation effective Dec. 1, the district said.
Officials acknowledged the district had safeguards against this kind of fraud, but said required procedures for independently verifying changes to a vendor's banking information were not followed.
The district's government crime insurance included coverage for fraudulent impersonation, but it required the district to make and document a reasonable effort to verify payment instructions through a method other than email before transferring funds. In a Nov. 1 determination letter, EMC Insurance said no such verification had been attempted before the payment and denied the claim, according to the district.
A separate cyber insurance policy authorized a $25,000 payment, and the district's bank recovered $4,051.47. After subtracting those amounts from the $92,180 payment, the district expects an unrecovered loss of $63,128.53. A $2,500 deductible was applied in the cyber insurer's settlement calculation, the district said.
Going forward, the district said it will require staff to independently verify vendor banking information through a method other than email and to document that verification before any funds are transferred.
The episode highlights a growing risk for public agencies: business email compromise schemes, in which attackers insert themselves into legitimate email threads and redirect payments to accounts they control. School districts, which often move large sums for construction, transportation and services, can be attractive targets, and insurers increasingly require documented out-of-band verification before covering losses.