Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Madison Focal

Madison's independent voice

Local

Madison's East Side Overflows with Shelter Debate as Neighbors Demand a Say

A temporary homeless shelter at an East Washington Avenue hotel opened with just five days' notice, sparking anger among east side residents who say their neighborhood bears an unfair share of the city's homelessness crisis. As the Bartillon shelter runs a waitlist of 182 people, officials and advocates say they are running out of time and options.

Madison's East Side Overflows with Shelter Debate as Neighbors Demand a Say

MADISON, Wis. — An overflow shelter for homeless men that opened this month at a Comfort Inn & Suites on East Washington Avenue drew sharp questions and raw emotion at a neighborhood meeting Tuesday night, as east side residents pressed city and county officials over why their community was chosen and why they learned about it only days before the doors opened.

Madison Street Medicine began operating the temporary shelter on Nov. 5. Neighbors were notified five days earlier.

"My first thought was, how can they do that without talking to anybody?" said Nathan Noordhoek, president of the Greater Sandburg Neighborhood Association.

The frustration was not confined to process. Several residents argued that homeless services are not spread evenly across the city and that the east side repeatedly ends up hosting them.

"We all know that people that are homeless need help," said Ted Turnquist, who has lived in the neighborhood for 45 years. "But why does it have to be in our neighborhood all the time?"

The numbers behind the scramble are stark. Madison's former men's shelter on Zeier Road averaged 352 men per night last winter. Its replacement on Bartillon Drive has a capacity of 250 — and as of Monday, 182 people were on its waitlist.

Madison Street Medicine Executive Director Brenda Konkel said her organization looked at numerous sites before turning to hotels, running into obstacles with zoning, building requirements and available space.

County officials described a race against the arrival of cold weather. "We know how urgent this is for our neighbors," said Melissa Mennig, housing access and affordability manager for Dane County Human Services.

The tension in the room also came from those living through the crisis. One attendee experiencing homelessness said the city keeps repeating the same short-term fixes.

"This crisis has been going on for a long time," the attendee said. "We keep doing the same thing, and this is just another Band-Aid that happens every single year."

The hotel shelter can house up to 50 men and is staffed around the clock. It functions as an extension of the Bartillon Drive shelter, drawing from the same waitlist and admitting guests by invitation only. Men staying at the hotel must move to Bartillon when a bed there becomes available.

The current hotel contract runs through December. Madison Street Medicine and Dane County are continuing to search for another location to carry people experiencing homelessness through the rest of the winter — a search that, like the one that led to the hotel, is unfolding on a tight clock and, so far, without a clear answer for neighbors who say they want to be part of the conversation.

More from The Madison Focal