Local
Madison Parents and Teachers Push for Transparency in School Staffing Decisions
Parents and educators are demanding answers after a kindergarten class at Erlanger Elementary was merged mid-semester, exposing deeper frustrations with how Madison schools allocate staff. A School Board member calls the formula 'fundamentally broken,' while district administrators defend the process as transparent and needs-based.
MADISON â When Heidi Andrew's daughter began kindergarten at Erlanger Elementary School this fall, her class had nine students. About four weeks later, Andrew learned that class would be combined with another of the same size, doubling the room without warning.
Andrew said the sudden change left families scrambling and raised questions about whether the merged class could meet students' needs. More than two-thirds of Erlanger students are economically disadvantaged, according to state data.
"Nobody warned us that this was a possibility until it happened to us, so it's not very clear," Andrew said. "It is not very transparent."
The consolidation at Erlanger, formerly Lindbergh Elementary on the city's northeast side, has become a flashpoint in a broader debate over how Madison Metropolitan School District leaders assign staff to schools and whether those decisions adequately account for student needs. Families and staff at Kennedy Elementary have raised similar concerns after learning of proposed cuts earlier this year.
"My feeling right now is that we are waiting for kids to fail," said Anna Mei Piro, a special education teacher at Kennedy. "We have to continually prove that we need the support anew every year, and the only way we can prove that is by showing the kids are harmed somehow. And there has to be a better system than one that waits for kids to get hurt."
District administrators defended the staffing process in an interview. Carlettra Stanford, associate superintendent of elementary schools, and Bob Soldner, assistant superintendent of finances, said decisions follow School Board policy, weigh student needs and are transparent.
The process typically starts in January or February with a formula largely based on enrollment. Principals receive a base number of staff and decide how to deploy them. Adjustments can continue through summer until the district's annual fall count on the third Friday of September.
This year, Madison schools enrolled several hundred fewer students than last year despite initial projections that enrollment would hold steady. Elementary class sizes are smaller on average, and more classes fall below the School Board's recommended minimum of 15 students.
In Erlanger's case, Stanford and Soldner said the district waited to see whether enrollment would fluctuate before combining the kindergarten classes a few weeks into the year. Keeping two sections would have left both far below the minimum target, they said, while the consolidated class remains within the district's optimum range. A kindergarten teacher from Erlanger was moved to another elementary school that was overcapacity and needed an additional teacher.
Soldner said mid-year consolidations are a "normal occurrence," though the district tries to avoid them. "We wouldn't move a teacher from a school unless there's a demonstrated need or increased attendance at another school," he said.
The district determines staffing for special education and other needs-based positions through several channels. Schools eligible for Title I federal aid receive additional funding that can be directed toward staff, Stanford said, and schools with certain student groups performing in the bottom 5% of Title I schools receive more resources.
The preliminary budget approved in June initially added about 11 full-time positions. The final budget passed in October added about 27, most of them for staff supporting students with disabilities, Soldner said.
Principals also influence class sizes through how they allocate staff within their buildings. Under district policy, principals can decide the number of class sections, meaning they could reduce class sizes in one grade by increasing them in another, Stanford said.
"Those conversations usually happen with school administration, and not so much with the actual teachers from the building," Stanford said. "But we do know that the teachers are having conversations with the principals around where they see the various needs are for their school."
Leaders of Madison Teachers Inc. said the staffing formula is something the union wants to work on with district leaders, describing the current process as opaque. Union president Andrea Missureli said the group wants to ensure schools are fully staffed, and executive director Jeff Knight said more staff feedback before major decisions would help.
School Board member Nicki Vander Meulen has posted comments on social media supporting Erlanger parents and calling for a broader review of staff allocation. "I think it's fundamentally broken," Vander Meulen said in an interview, adding that the formula is not transparent and can be "obtuse" in how it factors in student needs. "It feels like we're playing Jenga with children, and it just upsets me a little bit."
As the district prepares to begin staffing allocations for the 2027-28 school year, Andrew hopes administrators will make changes to improve transparency.
"Trying to figure out the policy, and how these things are made and how these things are decided, has become my second job," she said.