Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Madison Focal

Madison's independent voice

Local

Two Arrested in Madison Southwest Side Homicide Investigation

Madison police arrested Andreus Nathaniel, 23, and Deja Harrell, 25, on potential felony murder and armed robbery charges in connection with the October 28 death of 46-year-old Luke Weaver on Raymond Road.

Two Arrested in Madison Southwest Side Homicide Investigation

Madison police have arrested two people in connection with the death of a 46-year-old man whose body was found on the city's southwest side in late October.

Andreus Nathaniel, 23, and Deja Harrell, 25, were taken into custody Monday and booked into the Dane County Jail on potential charges of felony murder and armed robbery as a party to a crime, according to the Madison Police Department.

The arrests follow a weeks-long investigation that began around 3:40 p.m. on Wednesday, Oct. 28, when officers were called to the 5800 block of Raymond Road and found a person dead. Police initially described the death as suspicious and announced the next day that they were investigating it as a homicide. The victim was later identified as Luke Weaver.

On Monday, detectives from the department's Violent Crime Unit, the Special Weapons and Tactics team, Community Policing officers and the Gang and Neighborhood Crime Abatement Team served search warrants at two separate homes, police said. The coordinated operation led to the arrests of Nathaniel and Harrell.

Police did not release additional details about what the search warrants uncovered or how the two suspects are alleged to have been involved. The investigation remains active, and anyone with information is urged to contact Madison Area Crime Stoppers.

The case adds to a difficult stretch of violent crime in the Madison area this fall. In recent weeks, authorities have responded to a fatal head-on crash in Jefferson County, a shooting that left a deputy dead during a gun show, and a house fire in Beloit that killed two children. Community leaders have repeatedly called for expanded violence-prevention resources and stronger neighborhood policing as the city grapples with the aftermath of several high-profile incidents.

Felony murder charges in Wisconsin can be filed when a person is alleged to have caused a death during the commission of another felony, such as armed robbery, even if they did not directly carry out the killing. A party-to-a-crime designation means prosecutors believe a defendant aided or abetted the offense.

Nathaniel and Harrell are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Formal charges are expected to be reviewed by the Dane County District Attorney's Office in the coming days.

More from The Madison Focal