Local
Madison Body Camera Debate: Schools, Privacy and 15-Day Video Release Rule Under Scrutiny
Madison's body camera workgroup clashed Tuesday over whether officers should record in schools and how fast footage from critical incidents should be released, with a proposed 15-day deadline drawing resistance from prosecutors and state investigators ahead of a 2027 rollout.
Madison's effort to equip police officers with body cameras is running into hard questions about where the cameras should roll and how quickly the public should see what they capture.
A city workgroup met Tuesday evening for nearly three hours to review two draft policies: one governing when officers use body-worn cameras, and another setting rules for releasing police video after deadly or other critical incidents. Neither policy is final, and several provisions remain unresolved as the city prepares to expand camera use in early 2027.
The most contentious discussion centered on a proposal that would generally bar officers from recording on elementary, middle and high school grounds, with exceptions for imminent threats to life or serious injury.
Sgt. Jason Baumgart, representing the Madison Professional Police Officers Association, argued that limiting recording could leave key moments undocumented. He said officers could record more and redact sensitive material later.
"I think we can record a lot more and redact it on the back end," Baumgart said. "And if we're introducing this technology and this SOP, I would personally, I'd rely more heavily on let's record more and redact more on the back end so there's no questions about why wasn't your camera on."
District 13 Alder Tag Evers backed allowing officers to record situations that could escalate. But Madison Police Assistant Chief Matt Tye raised concerns about student privacy and noted the school district had not been consulted.
"We haven't talked to the school district. They have certain privacy rights," Tye said. "I don't know how that changes if they request us to turn off the cameras and they don't want the cameras on."
The group also weighed whether recording rules should differ among elementary, middle and high schools.
Officers also pressed for clarity on when cameras must be activated or deactivated during investigations. Under the draft, officers would generally record traffic stops, arrests and interviews, but exceptions would let them stop recording when victims or witnesses ask as a condition of cooperating.
Officer Jordan Strachota questioned how those exceptions would hold up when a situation shifts.
"Additionally, things are always evolving rapidly in our encounters," Strachota said. "And just because someone's cooperative one minute doesn't mean that they're going to be cooperative the next minute."
The workgroup also took up officers' ability to review recordings, supervisory oversight, and the balance between transparency and privacy.
A separate draft policy would govern the release of video after officer-involved deaths and other critical incidents. It would cover not only body camera footage but also squad car video and recordings submitted by members of the public.
One proposal calls for releasing footage within 15 days, though members also discussed 60- and 90-day alternatives. District 19 Alder John Guequierre, who chairs the workgroup, said the Dane County district attorney and the Wisconsin Department of Justice's Division of Criminal Investigation have not signed off on the 15-day timeline.
"They're just not prepared to say hey, go ahead with your 15 days," Guequierre said. "We'll probably do it case by case. We'll set a goal in those kinds of cases where there's a police involved death and try to make that a common thing."
The release deadline remains unresolved.
The city has already approved funding for an expanded body camera rollout expected to begin in early 2027. Some specialized Madison police units have previously used the technology.
Workgroup members approved several amendments Tuesday, but other proposals need more discussion. Neither policy has been finalized.
The group is scheduled to meet again Dec. 1, with plans to introduce the policies to the Common Council on Dec. 8. A final council vote could come Jan. 12, 2027, though that timeline remains tentative.