Local
Judge Rejects Plea Deals for Kentucky Troopers in Beating Case as Victim Seeks Harsher Sentences
A federal judge on Monday rejected plea agreements for two Kentucky State Police troopers accused in a 2020 beating that left a Hardin County man disabled, prompting the victim to call for longer prison terms and accountability for nine other officers.
LOUISVILLE, Ky. â A federal judge on Monday rejected plea agreements for two Kentucky State Police troopers charged in connection with a 2020 beating that left a Hardin County man permanently disabled, a decision the victim welcomed as he pushes for stiffer penalties and broader accountability.
Justin Halcomb, whose account was featured in an investigative series on excessive force by state troopers, said the ruling offered a measure of relief. "I was just like 'Well, thank God,'" he said.
The case dates to 1:30 a.m. in 2020, when Halcomb was driving to visit his first wife's grave. He noticed a car following closely and, unaware it was a police vehicle, sped up before braking. The officer then activated his lights. What followed was captured in part on video.
"They swarmed me, tased me two times and then handcuffed me behind my back," Halcomb said. "Then they just started stomping on me, choking me, stomping me, punching me, kicking me in the face. They kicked out almost all my jaw teeth."
Halcomb said the assault left him disabled and cost him his marriage and his job. "The only thing it hasn't took from me is the last few breaths I have in my body," he said.
Three troopers seen in the video â Thomas Czartorski, Cameron Wright and Jerrod Lewis â were indicted in connection with four separate incidents, including Halcomb's. On Monday, a federal judge rejected Czartorski's plea agreement, which had called for two and a half years in prison. Wright's plea agreement was also denied. No additional information was immediately available about Lewis.
Halcomb said he does not wish to see the officers' lives destroyed entirely, but he believes a fair sentence would be substantially longer. "I think a fair sentence would be at least like 10 years â 10 or 12 years or something," he said. "I mean, that's enough time to sit and think about what you did."
He also called on the nine other officers involved that night to acknowledge their actions. "When I leave my house, I'm still looking over my shoulder, because those nine are still out there," he said.
A spokesperson for the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Kentucky said U.S. Attorney Kyle Bumgarner is the only person authorized to comment on the case, but he was not immediately available.
The rejected pleas mean the cases against Czartorski and Wright will proceed, though it was not immediately clear whether new agreements will be negotiated or the matters will head to trial. The indictments span four separate incidents, suggesting a broader pattern of alleged misconduct that has drawn scrutiny to the state police agency.
For Halcomb, the court proceedings are a painful but necessary reckoning. "It was horrible," he said of the night in 2020. "It was the most horrible experience of my life."