Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Indianapolis Focal

Indianapolis's independent voice

Politics

Clark County Democrats File Recount Petition in Tight Indiana Senate Race

The Clark County Democratic Party has requested a manual recount of all 86 precincts in Senate District 45 after Republican Sen. Chris Garten won by fewer than 300 votes amid technical voting issues. Garten, who was sworn in Tuesday, has also filed for a recount in four Jeffersonville precincts.

Clark County Democrats File Recount Petition in Tight Indiana Senate Race

The Clark County Democratic Party has formally requested a manual recount of all 86 voting precincts in Indiana Senate District 45, escalating a high-stakes dispute over a race that Republican incumbent Sen. Chris Garten won by fewer than 300 votes.

The petition, filed Wednesday by Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, asks the Indiana Recount Commission to re-examine ballots across the district, which covers Clark County and part of Floyd County. Hampton’s filing asserts that votes “were not correctly counted and returned” and points to a series of technical problems on Election Day, including a ballot scanner that jammed at Jeffersonville High School and had to be replaced.

“No one has determined whether each ballot cast at Jeffersonville High School was counted once and only once, or how, or whether, the ballots counted by the two machines were combined in the results reported for the Jeffersonville High School precincts,” the petition states. It also cites poll pad issues at three or more other locations.

The recount request follows a chaotic post-election period in Clark County. Last week, the Clark County Election Board voted not to count ballots cast at Jeffersonville High School, prompting Hampton to file a lawsuit Monday seeking to delay certification of the Senate race and the county auditor’s race, where Republican Monty Snelling defeated Democrat Antonio Veals by 257 votes. Hampton has also requested a recount in that contest.

A judge granted a temporary restraining order preventing Garten from being sworn in, but the Indiana Supreme Court lifted that ruling. Garten was sworn in Tuesday during the legislature’s Organization Day, where he was also elected Senate President Pro Tempore. That same day, Garten filed his own recount petition with the Indiana Recount Commission, requesting a manual recount of four Jeffersonville precincts. He said he was “taking this action because I believe election integrity is too important to become a political talking point, unlike my Democrat counterparts.”

Garten previously dismissed the Democrats’ concerns as “political theater.”

Attorney Mickey Weber, representing the Democratic Party, said Garten’s comments have been misleading and that “it’s hard to see how it could be anything other than intentional.” Weber clarified that the party is seeking a recount and a hearing to determine whether it is possible to know who won. If not, a special election could be the next step. Hampton’s petition asks to consolidate his filing with Garten’s and calls for a special election.

Meanwhile, Clark County Clerk Ryan Lynch, a Republican, says his office is ready to certify the results but has been blocked by the court order stemming from Hampton’s lawsuit. “We are ready to certify. We have been ready,” Lynch said in a Wednesday news release. “The law tells my office what to do and when to do it. A court told us to stop, and we have respected that. Now we are asking for permission to finish the job.”

Lynch’s attorney, Larry Wilder, said the clerk is “caught in the middle” and is not taking a position on the outcome. “We are simply asking to let the Clerk do what the law requires,” Wilder said. “We take no position on who should win.”

The clerk has asked the court and the Indiana Recount Commission to allow him to send the county’s vote totals to the state. Special Judge Jason Mount recused himself from the case after Garten requested a new judge, and online court filings do not yet show a replacement.

The Indiana Recount Commission is expected to meet Monday in Indianapolis. Staff with the Indiana State Board of Accounts are scheduled to be in Southern Indiana Tuesday to begin sorting through ballot information.

The dispute has drawn attention to the reliability of voting equipment and the integrity of a narrow legislative race in a key swing region. With control of a Senate seat hanging in the balance, local Democrats say a full recount is necessary to ensure every valid ballot is counted accurately.

“The votes were not correctly counted and returned,” Hampton said in his filing, a claim that will now be tested before the state recount commission.

More from The Indianapolis Focal