Politics
NetChoice Sues Indiana Over Social Media Restrictions for Minors
A tech industry group representing Google, Meta, and TikTok filed a federal lawsuit challenging Indiana's new law that restricts social media access for children under 16, arguing it violates the First Amendment. The law, set to take effect Jan. 1, 2027, requires age verification and limits addictive features unless a parent consents.
A major technology industry trade group has filed a federal lawsuit challenging Indiana's new law that restricts social media access for children under 16, setting up a legal battle over free speech and child safety that could have national implications.
NetChoice, whose members include Google, Meta, TikTok, Amazon, OpenAI, and Reddit, filed the complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana on Nov. 18. The group argues that the law, House Bill 1408, violates the First Amendment by requiring social media companies to verify users' ages and impose restrictions on minors' accounts.
The law, approved earlier this year, prohibits children under 16 from accessing social media platforms that use algorithms and addictive features such as autoplay and continuous scrolling. Minors can gain access with parental consent, but platforms must then disable those features for underage users. The restrictions apply to platforms with at least $1 billion in worldwide revenue in one of the past three years, a significant number of daily active users under 16, and a primary function of uploading and viewing contentâa description that could cover TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram.
In its complaint, NetChoice contends that the age-verification requirement places an unconstitutional burden on Hoosiers by forcing them to provide identifying information to companies. The group also argues that the state has not demonstrated a sufficient justification for restricting minors' access.
"The First Amendment certainly does not tolerate government efforts to suppress constitutionally protected speech because the government thinks minors spend too much time engaging with it," the complaint states.
The lawsuit echoes arguments that have succeeded in other states. A federal judge blocked a 2024 Utah law, finding it likely violated the free speech rights of social media companies as well as Utah kids and adults. Similar laws in Louisiana and Arkansas have also been struck down on First Amendment grounds. Legal challenges are ongoing in Maryland and California.
Indiana lawmakers anticipated a court fight. During debate over the bill, they studied Florida's language, which had survived a legal challenge, in an effort to make the law more defensible. State Sen. Jeff Raatz, R-Richmond, acknowledged the likelihood of litigation in February.
"We will probably be challenged in a court of law," Raatz said. "Is it worth it? Absolutely."
The legislation initially stalled amid constitutional concerns but regained momentum after the death of a missing Fishers teenager, Hailey Buzbee, earlier this year. Supporters, including Indiana Secretary of Education Katie Jenner, have compared the restrictions to laws banning minors from alcohol and drugs, emphasizing the need to protect children from predatory behavior and addictive platform designs.
Attorney General Todd Rokita intends to defend the law, according to a statement from spokesperson Slayde Settle. The office believes the law is necessary to hold NetChoice's members "responsible for the addictive features used to attract our kids."
NetChoice and civil liberties groups like the ACLU argue that age-verification mandates chill protected speech because adults cannot access platforms without surrendering personal data and forfeiting anonymity. The complaint also dismisses the state's rationale, comparing the restrictions to prohibiting minors from obtaining library cards simply because some might encounter inappropriate books.
"Indiana could not restrict all minors under 16 from obtaining library cards just because some might come across Fifty Shades of Grey, or because others might spend two or more hours a day reading The Hunger Games," the complaint reads. "For the same reasons, Indiana may not restrict minors from creating accounts on 'social media' services just because some may spend more time on them than Indiana thinks they should."
Unless a court intervenes, the law is scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1, 2027. The case is being watched closely as states across the country grapple with how to regulate social media's impact on young people without running afoul of the Constitution.