Local
Irvington Community Schools Faces Charter Revocation Threat Over $1.5M Deficit, Staffing Crisis
The Indianapolis mayor's office has warned one of the city's oldest charter networks that it could lose its charter after financial mismanagement and staff absences forced two days of canceled classes. Irvington Community Schools must prove by Dec. 8 that it can stay solvent and fully staffed, or face closure.
Irvington Community Schools, one of Indianapolis's oldest charter networks, is fighting for its survival after the mayor's Office of Education Innovation (OEI) issued a formal notice warning that its charters could be revoked. The warning, delivered in a letter Friday to board chair Keith Young, cites a projected $1.5 million deficit for the current school year and staffing shortages that forced the network to cancel classes on Thursday and Friday of last week.
The OEI, which authorizes the network's three schools, ordered Irvington to resume full operations by Monday and to confirm in writing by 5 p.m. Sunday that each campus had enough staff to open safely. In a Facebook post Sunday evening, the network announced that schools would reopen Monday. "We are grateful to our staff and teachers for reopening schools tomorrow," the statement read. "It is so important that we continue to provide a high-quality education for our students."
The notice of revocation is among the most severe actions OEI can take. It invokes Indiana law allowing charter termination for financial instability and organizational failure. "Families must be able to rely on the schools to provide safe, consistent instruction," the letter stated. "Financial and organizational instability cannot be allowed to become a continuing barrier to students' access to education."
Irvington must respond by Dec. 8, either demonstrating why each charter should not be revoked or proposing corrective measures. OEI has requested evidence of the network's ability to maintain adequate staffing and meet payroll, along with an updated cash flow forecast. The notice also requires the board to cooperate with OEI "in preparing for an orderly transition if closure becomes necessary."
The financial crisis has been building for years. The network ended the last school year with a $2.85 million deficit, and enrollment this fall came in at 710 studentsâwell below the 817 the network had budgeted for, according to board meeting minutes from August and September. Staff called out in protest last week amid the shortfall, prompting the cancellations.
In a Nov. 14 Facebook statement, CEO Rachel Maldonado, who took the helm in July, said she uncovered financial problems dating back to at least 2024. She attributed part of the deficit to the network's use of temporary federal COVID-19 relief funds to hire staff, maintaining those staffing levels after the funding expired. Congress approved three aid packages in 2020 and 2021, and Indiana schools received $2.9 billion from the Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief Fund, which had to be spent by the end of 2024.
"Irvington Community Schools used federal COVID relief funds to hire more staff but kept those staffing levels after the funding ended," Maldonado wrote. "Enrollment also fell, leaving schools with less revenue while spending continued. Significant cuts began in January 2026, but they haven't been enough. The path ahead will be difficult, but there's hope for improvement and it's not too late."
In a voicemail to staff last week, Maldonado said the deficit for this year exceeds $1.5 million. The network has already instituted two rounds of layoffs, paused its contract for substitute teaching services, and temporarily suspended contributions to employee retirement plans. Those cuts sparked outrage among staff and led to the resignations of the special education director and high school principal.
OEI's oversight of the network has been escalating. Last year, the office placed Irvington on a Level 1 notice of concern over financial reporting requirements. In October, it raised the warning to Level 3âthe most seriousâafter the network needed a short-term loan to make payroll following an "unexpected insurance expense."
OEI Director Shaina Cavazos said the office had repeatedly cautioned Irvington and other schools about using pandemic relief funds in ways that would create deficits once the money ran out. "At the end of the day, all we can do is give that advice, have those conversations," Cavazos said. "But the schoolâeither at the administration level, at the board levelâthey have to make the decisions that allow them to continue to operate."
The Indianapolis charter school board is scheduled to hold a renewal hearing on Irvington's three charters on Dec. 10. Cavazos said no decision will be made that night, but she expects the office to communicate a decision within 60 days. "Our decision cannot be made until we are provided the response and corrective action from them," she said. "One of which is, you must return to school."
The turmoil follows a turbulent period for the network's governing board, which last year restarted its search for a new CEO after students and staff protested a candidate who also served as board chair. As the Dec. 8 deadline approaches, families and educators are left wondering whether one of the city's most established charter networks can stabilize in timeâor whether Indianapolis is about to lose it altogether.