Local
Indianapolis Councilors Draft Flock Camera Oversight After Officer Misuse Scandal
Two Indianapolis city-county councilors are drafting new rules for Flock license plate cameras, including a public meeting before any surveillance contract is signed, after five IMPD officers were charged with misusing the system. Councilor Jesse Brown says his earlier proposal has been kept off the agenda since July.
Indianapolis City-County Councilor Jesse Brown and Council Vice President John Barth are drafting a new policy to regulate the city's Flock license plate reading cameras, aiming to bring the measure forward in December after months of public pressure and a police misconduct scandal.
The two councilors held a community meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 10, to gather public input on the proposal. Barth said a central element would require a public meeting before any surveillance technology contract is executed.
"One of the elements that we want to add is before any surveillance technology contracts can be put into place and accepted â that there be a public meeting," Barth said. "The public can come in and share their thoughts about the technology prior to it actually being, the contract being executed."
The push follows a September revelation that the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department arrested five officers for allegedly misusing Flock cameras. The department has said the cameras help solve crimes including fatal hit-and-runs, armed robberies and a kidnapping, and IMPD leases 301 of the devices.
Brown said he introduced a measure earlier this year to establish city oversight but has been frustrated that it has not reached the council floor.
"Since July, they've been keeping this off of the council's agenda every month, so that we don't put new guardrails in about Flock cameras," Brown said.
Brown took both of the bicycle tours organized by local activist Frederick Miller III, who shows residents where cameras are located and explains how they are used. Miller led about 75 people on his first tour in July; his second, held between Halloween and the midterm election, drew only three riders. He plans to pause the tours until spring and share information through livestream sessions on YouTube over the winter.
"My goal has been to get people from the city council to be part of the tours because it's really up to the city council and the police department on how this technology works," Miller said.
IMPD Chief Tanya Terry told reporters in September that the department will hold people accountable, saying "nobody is above the law." She also voiced support for statewide minimum standards for responsible use of the technology.
"I think that there should be some minimum standards that we all abide by. That's the expectation of the community," Terry said.
The department presented a draft of a new Flock policy to the Indianapolis General Orders Board on Oct. 20. An early draft obtained by reporters underlines a prohibition on personal use and adds new search-auditing guardrails. IMPD said in an email that it is currently operating under those policies.
The department also provided a document cataloging Automated License Plate Reader successes, citing cases including fatal hit-and-runs, armed robberies and a kidnapping.
Miller said he hopes the pressure produces change while keeping the debate peaceful.
"I think that we have a history in our country of different types of revolutions and changes. For me, we have to do it based on what identifies with us, what we feel is most comfortable, and what pushes us to grow," Miller said.
The councilors' proposal is one of several efforts across Indiana seeking more transparency and regulation of Flock cameras, including a Michigan City police officer's resignation in September amid an investigation into improper camera searches.