Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Indianapolis Focal

Indianapolis's independent voice

Local

Indiana's Coal Ash Takeover Plan Draws Growing Opposition as EPA Decision Looms

Environmental groups warn that Indiana's proposed state-run coal ash program is weaker than federal rules and could endanger public health, while IDEM insists it is ready to enforce a robust permitting system.

Indiana's Coal Ash Takeover Plan Draws Growing Opposition as EPA Decision Looms

A plan for Indiana to take over federal oversight of coal ash waste is facing mounting opposition from environmental advocates, who say the state's regulations are too weak to protect Hoosiers from toxic pollution.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency proposed in September approving the Indiana Department of Environmental Management's application to run its own coal combustion residuals permitting program. The EPA is expected to make a final decision by March 14, 2027.

Coal ash, the residue left after burning coal at power plants, contains pollutants such as arsenic, chromium, lead, and mercury—substances linked to cancer, heart disease, and reproductive failure. If not properly managed, the waste can contaminate groundwater and spread as airborne dust.

At a public hearing on November 12, representatives from groups including the Hoosier Environmental Council, Just Transition Northwest Indiana, and Earthjustice testified against the handover. They argued that Indiana's rules exempt certain coal ash sites from permitting and would allow uses of the waste that federal regulations restrict.

"Indiana's coal ash permit program plainly fails to meet the legal test that Congress set for delegating authority to states," said Lauren Piette, a senior attorney at Earthjustice. "Indiana's program is not as protective as federal requirements. The EPA must deny Indiana's application."

Ashley Williams, executive director of Just Transition Northwest Indiana, said IDEM lacks the resources and staffing to properly enforce a new program. "Too many loopholes and too many questions remain for this program to be executed and enforced properly," she said.

Critics pointed to the Town of Pines in northwest Indiana, where coal ash was used as landscaping fill and construction material, contaminating the area so severely that it is now listed as an alternative Superfund site. Indra Frank, HEC's coal ash adviser, warned that recent state law could allow similar situations elsewhere. "The Town of Pines suffered because of coal ash spread on the land and used as fill, yet recent Indiana law allows the same thing to happen anywhere in the state," Frank said.

Indiana legislators this year passed a law stating that state regulations can be "no more stringent than" federal rules, preventing agencies from enacting stronger protections. Environmental advocates say this could force the state to weaken its rules further if the EPA rolls back federal coal ash standards.

IDEM officials defended the program at the hearing. Commissioner Clint Woods said the state would oversee more coal ash sites than any other state and that the department has invested significant resources into developing a program that is "protective, transparent and consistent with federal requirements."

Brian Wolff, IDEM's assistant commissioner of the Office of Land Quality, said the program will have 13 dedicated staff members and that hiring is already underway. He said the state would regulate coal ash reuse only when there is a risk of harm, comparing it to cooking oil that is unregulated unless burned in an industrial boiler.

Indiana has been developing its coal ash program since 2021 and finalized its application in June 2026. The EPA's decision will determine whether the state or the federal government oversees permitting at coal ash sites across Indiana.

More from The Indianapolis Focal