Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Denver Focal

Denver's independent voice

Local

Colorado Appeals Court Rules Wildlife Agency Illegally Ignored Public Comments on Access Rules

A state appeals court found Colorado Parks and Wildlife violated the State Administrative Procedure Act by soliciting public feedback online and then never presenting it to decision-makers. The ruling reverses a lower court and sends the 2023 state wildlife area rules back for reconsideration.

Colorado Appeals Court Rules Wildlife Agency Illegally Ignored Public Comments on Access Rules

A Colorado Court of Appeals panel ruled Thursday that Colorado Parks and Wildlife broke state law when it adopted 2023 regulations governing state wildlife areas, finding the agency solicited public comments through its online portal and then never presented those comments to the commissioners who approved the rules.

The decision reverses a district court ruling that had upheld the regulations, which restricted some state wildlife areas to hunters and anglers while barring wildlife watchers and other recreationists from the same lands.

The case began in April 2023, when CPW posted proposed changes to its state wildlife area rules and invited the public to weigh in through Engage CPW, an online engagement platform. Over a six-week comment period, the agency received 191 comments through the website and seven by email.

According to the appeals court opinion, CPW later conceded that those online comments were never presented to or considered by the decision-makers who finalized the rules, and that the comments were left out of the official rulemaking record.

The court found that CPW violated the State Administrative Procedure Act on two counts: it opened public comment through a communication method not identified in the official notice of rulemaking, and it failed to include the submitted comments in the record or weigh them before adopting the final rules.

"Colorado Parks and Wildlife invited the public to submit comments to its proposed state wildlife area rules on its online platform. Nearly 200 people did so," the opinion states. "But the agency concedes that those comments were never presented to or considered by the agency decision-makers who promulgated the final rules, nor were the comments included in the rulemaking record."

Stephen Hernick, the attorney representing Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness and Living River, said the disclosure caught the plaintiffs off guard.

"We had assumed that CPW had considered all public comments submitted," Hernick said. "We were frankly pretty stunned when CPW's attorneys told us, 'Actually, no, CPW didn't consider any of these comments that were submitted to Engage CPW.'"

Many of the comments opposed the proposed rules. Several objected to allowing hunters access to areas where wildlife viewers would be excluded, and others questioned rules that permitted hunting dogs in some areas while barring a member of the public from bringing a dog.

One commenter urged the agency to allow non-motorized boaters to use the areas for put-ins and take-outs, writing that such use "does not interfere with fishing or hunting." Another argued that CPW "may actually be harming wildlife and their habitat by arbitrarily favoring the activities of hunters and fishers who kill and remove wildlife from SWAs."

A Carbondale resident objected to restricting a stretch of the Roaring Fork River between Aspen and Glenwood Springs to hunters and anglers, writing that the river "should be allowed to all" and asking the agency to at least permit equitable access during certain times.

CPW manages roughly 350 lands and waters designated by the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission to protect wildlife populations and provide places for the public to view wildlife. The agency proposed the 2023 changes out of concern that growing visitation could harm habitat.

The court's opinion noted that CPW estimated about a quarter of the Engage CPW commenters generally supported the proposed changes.

Hernick said the agency's failure to acknowledge the error compounded the problem.

"The disappointing thing for us was that CPW didn't recognize this error, didn't recognize that, 'Oh, there was clearly some confusion here that we caused by encouraging people to submit comments to Engage CPW,'" he said. "I would like to think that a state agency in a situation like that would own up to its mistake."

He said the past three years of restrictions have limited public access to state wildlife areas and prioritized hunting and fishing over other forms of wildlife-related recreation.

"Essentially non-hunters and non-fishers were severely restricted in what they could do or even SWAs that they could access," Hernick said.

In an emailed statement, CPW said it is "still evaluating the Colorado Court of Appeals' recent decision and determining next steps."

The ruling sends the matter back to the lower court, and Hernick said he hopes the agency will return to the drawing board and consider the comments the public submitted.

More from The Denver Focal