Local
Denver Homeowner Wins Round Against Xcel Energy in Long-Running Outage Battle
Jim Smelley, a Southmoor Park resident, has fought Xcel Energy for years over chronic outages. After a judge sided with the utility, the Colorado Public Utilities Commission reopened his complaint, giving him a rare chance to hold the company accountable.
A Denver homeownerâs years-long fight with Xcel Energy over chronic power outages has taken a surprising turn in his favor, after state regulators reopened a complaint that had been dismissed by an administrative judge.
Jim Smelley, who lives in the Southmoor Park neighborhood, has endured more than 80 outages since 2023, including 34 in a single day on July 9, 2025, according to Xcelâs own data. The problems have disrupted his work, spoiled food, and damaged appliances, he said. At one point, a power pole near his house burst into flames.
âThere were 34 outages in one day, which living in a house like that isâ¦actually a little bit scary, honestly,â Smelley said. âYou worry that things are about to break all the time.â
His experience is not unique. A 2024 report from the Colorado Public Utilities Commission (PUC) found that the frequency and duration of Xcel outages steadily climbed between 2015 and 2024, hitting new highs in 2024. Outages have continued to rise in 2026, outpacing historical norms, according to a September PUC report.
That trend has persisted even as Xcel spends billions of ratepayer dollars on grid upgrades. In late 2024, the company proposed a nearly $5 billion plan to improve and replace poles, wires, and substations. Customers are now paying for that plan through higher bills.
âWe've got customers paying increasingly high bills and looking at rapidly expanding investmentâ¦while [they] unfortunately experience worse service than they have in the past,â PUC commissioner Megan Gilman said during a September meeting. She said the commission is considering new rules or higher penalties to reduce outages.
Xcel spokesperson Michelle Aguayo did not directly address the PUC report but said in a statement that âproviding safe, reliable energy our customers count on 24/7 is at the heart of what we do.â She cited challenges from extreme weather and wildfires, and said grid upgrades can cause short-term issues. âBut we are confident the long-term benefits will include increased reliability,â she said.
Smelley, who spent decades working in energy policy and even briefly worked for Xcel about 25 years ago, decided to file a formal complaint with the PUC in January 2026 without a lawyer. He did not seek monetary damages; instead, he asked the company to acknowledge a pattern of mistakes and fix the grid in his neighborhood.
Most consumer complaints never reach a hearing, and those that do often pit individuals against well-funded utility legal teams. Smelley said he spent hundreds of hours on the case and used an AI chatbot to help organize files and research case law. âThere is no way I could have ever gone up against this company without AI,â he said. âI would have lost instantly.â
In April, Xcel asked a judge to dismiss the complaint, arguing it was fixing the issues and that Smelley had not experienced an outage since early January. But just days after that filing, Smelleyâs power went out again, he later told the court.
In July, Judge Kelly A. Rosenberg sided with Xcel and recommended that the PUC close the complaint, finding that the company had shown there wasnât a pattern of continuing poor service. Smelley appealed, and in a rare move, the three-member PUC agreed with him on Nov. 4. The commission set aside the judgeâs decision and reopened the complaint, stating that âa reasonable factfinder could look at both the frequency and severity of the outages, and their underlying causes, and ultimately conclude that Mr. Smelleyâs property experienced a general pattern of inadequate service.â
âIt's very rare for an individual to prevail in the system...against somebody that the commission regulates, be that a household goods mover or a taxi company, let alone one of the large utilities,â said Jeff Ackermann, a former PUC chairman.
Smelley said he was elated by the ruling and plans to push ahead, calling witnesses and presenting more evidence. He hopes a judge will find that Xcel violated the law and order the company to complete fixes to his neighborhoodâs grid.
In the meantime, he has taken steps to reduce his reliance on Xcel. Last week, a crew installed rooftop solar panels on his home. He thought a battery was included, but a mix-up means it will take a few more weeks. Still, he was giddy when the panels were turned on.
âI feel like Iâm going to get my power back,â he said.