Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Dallas Focal

Dallas's independent voice

Local

Transplant Agency Sues Baylor Scott & White to Honor Brain-Dead New York Woman's Organ Donation

Gift of Life Alliance has asked a Dallas County court to force Baylor University Medical Center to keep Emanise Timothee on a ventilator so her organs can be recovered, arguing her 2016 donor registration is legally binding despite her family's opposition.

Transplant Agency Sues Baylor Scott & White to Honor Brain-Dead New York Woman's Organ Donation

A North Texas organ procurement organization has taken Baylor Scott & White to court over the hospital's refusal to proceed with organ recovery from a 38-year-old New York woman who was declared brain-dead this week, setting up a closely watched test of how far a registered donor's wishes can override a family's objections.

Gift of Life Alliance, formerly known as Southwest Transplant Alliance, filed a request for an emergency temporary restraining order Thursday in Dallas County Court. The agency wants Baylor University Medical Center in Dallas to maintain ventilator support for Emanise Timothee, who was declared dead under established neurological criteria at 2:10 p.m. on Nov. 17.

According to the lawsuit, Timothee's family told hospital officials they opposed organ donation, and Baylor informed the agency it would not allow the donation to go forward without a court order. The suit asks the court to guarantee continued ventilator support while the dispute is resolved.

Timothee enrolled in the New York State Donate Life Registry in Buffalo in 2016, authorizing the donation of her heart, liver, lungs, kidneys, intestines, pancreas, skin, blood vessels, bone and connective tissue, corneas and eyes for transplant and research, the filing states.

The suit argues that Texas law requires hospitals to assist in organ donations even when family members object. It cites the Texas Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act, which it says bars anyone other than the donor from making, amending or revoking a legally binding anatomical gift.

"The family's consent is not required, and its objection has no legal affect," the suit states. "Each hour of delay threatens the medical sustainability of organs that could save the lives of multiple patients waiting for transplant."

In a statement Friday evening, Gift of Life Alliance said it sought the order "to uphold the legally binding wishes of a deceased individual who, while living, made the selfless decision to register as an organ donor."

"The donor registry is legally binding and represents an individual's documented decision to give the gift of life at their death," the agency said. "That decision deserves to be honored and respected. Our responsibility is to advocate for the expressed wishes of registered donors while ensuring the donation process is handled with the utmost respect, compassion, and care."

The agency added that it recognizes the sensitivity of the situation and remains committed to working respectfully with all parties, but declined to comment further because the matter is in active litigation.

Baylor Scott & White declined to comment, citing the pending case. Court records indicate Timothee lived in Buffalo at the time she joined the registry, and efforts to reach her family were unsuccessful Friday night.

The case lands at the intersection of two principles that transplant systems have long struggled to balance: the autonomy of a person who made a documented decision to donate, and the grief and objections of surviving family members. Texas law, like federal rules governing organ procurement, generally treats a donor's registration as binding, but hospitals often seek court guidance when families resist.

For the thousands of Texans awaiting transplants, the dispute also carries practical stakes. Organs deteriorate quickly after brain death, and procurement agencies warn that delays can render otherwise viable hearts, livers and kidneys unusable. Gift of Life Alliance said in its filing that every hour of delay jeopardizes organs that could save multiple lives.

The restraining order request is now before a Dallas County judge. It was not immediately clear Friday night when the court would rule.

More from The Dallas Focal