Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Dallas Focal

Dallas's independent voice

Local

Arlington Pastor Convicted of $6 Million Fraud That Bilked 70 Victims Across Four Countries

A federal jury found Richard Reinaldo Garcia, 53, guilty of wire fraud and conspiracy after prosecutors showed he used his pulpit to steer more than $6 million from congregants and investors into personal accounts, a luxury SUV and a $1.6 million Mansfield home.

Arlington Pastor Convicted of $6 Million Fraud That Bilked 70 Victims Across Four Countries

ARLINGTON — A federal jury on Thursday convicted an Arlington pastor of running a years-long real estate and investment scheme that prosecutors say drained more than $6 million from at least 70 victims in the United States, Colombia, Mexico and the Dominican Republic.

Richard Reinaldo Garcia, 53, was found guilty of one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and three counts of wire fraud following a four-day trial before U.S. District Judge Mark T. Pittman in the Northern District of Texas. Each count carries a maximum penalty of 20 years in federal prison. Sentencing is set for March 4, 2027.

According to evidence presented at trial, Garcia and others solicited money from at least August 2021 through April 2025 for purported real estate ventures involving the purchase and resale of churches, as well as for promoting Christian music concerts. Investors were promised substantial returns, but prosecutors said Garcia diverted the funds to cover personal expenses and his businesses. When victims inquired about missing profits, he often claimed the money had been reinvested in other projects.

Garcia served as pastor at several Arlington churches during the scheme and used that position to encourage congregation members to contribute both money and labor to church-owned real estate projects, according to the evidence. The properties were remodeled and sold for profit while Garcia continued to solicit additional investments.

Prosecutors showed that Garcia controlled accounts tied to church-related entities — including Ministerio Gracia, Iglesia Gracia de Texas, Gracia Church of Texas and A Pesar de Todo, LLC — and instructed victims to wire money to those accounts and record the payments as donations to Gracia Church, even though the funds were meant for investments in the fraudulent scheme.

The trial also revealed how Garcia personally benefited. From about 2023 through October 2025, he directed more than $200,000 per year into his personal bank accounts, drove a 2023 Mercedes electric SUV and lived in a Mansfield property that sold for more than $1.6 million.

"This defendant didn't just take money from his victims," said Ryan Raybould, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Texas. "He abused personal relationships, exploited the trust people placed in him as a pastor and used false promises to convince victims in the U.S. and abroad to hand over their hard-earned savings. The jury saw through those lies."

R. Joseph Rothrock, special agent in charge of the FBI's Dallas field office, said the verdict reflects the damage done to victims' financial security. "The defendant's scheme betrayed the trust of his congregants and others and used deception to lure them into making investments in his fraudulent projects," Rothrock said. "The FBI remains committed to working alongside our law enforcement partners to protect the public from fraudsters who seek to enrich only themselves."

The FBI is asking anyone who believes they may have been a victim of the scheme to complete an online information request questionnaire posted on the bureau's website.

The case underscores the particular vulnerability of faith communities to affinity fraud, in which con artists leverage shared religious ties and personal trust to solicit money. North Texas has seen a string of such cases in recent years, and consumer advocates urge congregants to demand independent documentation and third-party oversight before committing savings to any investment pitched from the pulpit.

More from The Dallas Focal