Local
Darlie Routier's Lawyers File Appeal Citing New DNA, Fingerprint Evidence in 1996 Rowlett Murders
Attorneys for Darlie Routier, on death row for nearly 30 years for the 1996 stabbing of her 5-year-old son in Rowlett, filed a habeas corpus application Thursday citing unknown male DNA on a bloody sock and fingerprints not matching her or her ex-husband. The Innocence Project lawyer asks Texas' Court of Criminal Appeals to send the case back to Dallas County for review.
DALLAS â Attorneys for Darlie Routier, the Rowlett mother who has spent nearly three decades on Texas' death row for the 1996 stabbing of her 5-year-old son, filed a new appeal Thursday arguing that DNA, fingerprint and other forensic evidence points to an intruder rather than Routier.
The application for a writ of habeas corpus was submitted in Dallas County and to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. It asks the state's highest criminal court to remand the case to district court so the new evidence can be examined.
Routier, now 56, was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in 1997 for the killing of Damon Routier. She was not convicted in the death of his 6-year-old brother, Devon. Both boys were found stabbed in the family's home on Eagle Drive in Rowlett in June 1996, while Routier's husband and the couple's third child, an infant, were upstairs.
Routier has consistently said a man in dark clothing broke into the home and attacked the family. She told police the intruder fled through a utility room into the garage, and that she picked up a knife from the floor and placed it on the kitchen counter. She was slashed across the neck during the attack, according to court records, and screamed for her husband, who ran downstairs and began CPR on Devon while Routier called 911.
Prosecutors at trial argued that Routier's account did not match the physical evidence and accused her of staging the scene to implicate a fictitious intruder. She was arrested by Rowlett police days after the killings.
The new appeal, filed by attorney Vanessa Potkin of The Innocence Project, centers on what the defense describes as a wealth of newly available forensic material. Among the claims: unknown male DNA was found on a sock stained with the boys' blood that was recovered near the home. The defense argues the intruder carried the sock and dropped it while fleeing.
The filing also cites fingerprints recovered from the murder weapon and from the door Routier said the intruder used to escape â prints that the appeal says do not belong to Routier or her ex-husband.
"There's a wealth of newly available forensic evidence that supports Ms. Routier's innocence and dismantles the false narrative the State used to wrongfully convict Ms. Routier," Potkin said in a statement.
The Innocence Project is a national criminal justice reform organization that uses DNA testing and scientific advances to investigate suspected wrongful convictions. Potkin's request asks the Court of Criminal Appeals to order a lower court review of the new evidence, a step that could eventually lead to a new trial or relief for Routier.
Routier's case has drawn sustained public attention in North Texas and beyond, with supporters long arguing that the forensic record was incomplete and that questions about the intruder account were never fully resolved. Her appeals have wound through state and federal courts for years.
The filing lands as Texas continues to grapple with questions about the reliability of forensic evidence used in capital cases. For Rowlett and the wider Dallas County community, the appeal reopens one of the region's most closely watched murder cases and raises the prospect that a conviction nearly three decades old could be revisited.
The Court of Criminal Appeals has not yet indicated whether it will grant the request for remand. Routier remains on death row.