Local
Dallas Nonprofit Sues Baylor University Medical Center Over Refusal to Recover Organs from Brain-Dead Woman
Gift of Life Alliance filed an emergency lawsuit in Dallas County court after Baylor University Medical Center refused to recover organs from a brain-dead 38-year-old registered donor because her family objected. The nonprofit argues Texas law bars others from revoking a donor's decision and that organ viability is time-sensitive.
A Dallas-based nonprofit that facilitates organ donations has filed an emergency lawsuit against Baylor University Medical Center, alleging the hospital unlawfully refused to recover organs from a brain-dead patient after her family objected, despite her long-standing status as a registered organ donor.
The petition, filed Thursday in Dallas County court, asks a judge to order the hospital to proceed with organ recovery for Emanise Timothee, a 38-year-old woman whom Baylor doctors declared brain dead on Tuesday. Timothee enrolled in the New York State Donate Life Registry in 2016, giving permission to donate her organs, eyes, and tissues for transplantation and research, according to the complaint.
Gift of Life Alliance, the nonprofit named in the filing, confirmed Timothee's registration and that she never revoked it. Baylor officials had contacted the organization to facilitate the donation process, the petition states. But when Timothee's family told hospital staff they did not want the donation to proceed, Baylor administrators informed the nonprofit they would not move forward with any organ recovery operation without a court order. The petition does not specify the family's reasons for opposing the donation.
Attorneys for Gift of Life Alliance argue that Texas law generally prohibits outside parties from revoking a person's decision to be an organ donor. They filed for a temporary restraining order and temporary injunction, seeking to compel the hospital to honor Timothee's registered wishes.
In their complaint, the nonprofit's lawyers emphasized the urgent nature of the situation, writing that organ viability for brain-dead patients is "time limited" because "a donor's physiology can become unstable quickly," potentially rendering organs unsuitable for transplant. They added that they have "no objection to the family's continued reasonable visitation" as long as it does not interfere with the recovery process.
As of Saturday, no hearing date had been scheduled, and spokespeople for Baylor University Medical Center did not respond to requests for comment. A relative of Timothee, reached by phone, referred a reporter to another family member who did not immediately respond to an interview request Saturday evening.
The case highlights a tension between a patient's documented end-of-life wishes and a family's objections, a scenario that can arise even when a donor has taken formal steps to register. Under Texas law, a person's decision to donate is legally binding and can only be revoked by the donor themselves, making the hospital's refusal potentially a violation of state statute.
Gift of Life Alliance is seeking a swift court intervention, warning that further delay could permanently prevent Timothee's organs from being donated to patients in need. The lawsuit underscores the critical importance of honoring advance directives and the legal framework designed to protect a donor's autonomy even after death.