Politics
Chicago's CFO Resignation Sparks Audit Push as Mayor Johnson Defends Budget Numbers
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson insists his administration's financial reporting is sound after CFO Ashlee Gabrysch resigned over a dispute about budget figures, while a dozen aldermen push for an independent three-year audit of city finances.
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson on Tuesday defended his administration's financial reporting in his first press conference since his chief financial officer abruptly resigned, as a growing group of aldermen demanded an independent audit of the city's books.
Ashlee Gabrysch stepped down Friday, citing a dispute over information the Johnson administration provided to the City Council as part of the mayor's 2027 budget plan. In her resignation statement, she wrote that the CFO's statements about city finances "are relied upon by investors, ratings agencies, City Council, and taxpayers" and must be "scrupulously" accurate and complete.
Gabrysch said continuing in the role "would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations." She was the third CFO to leave the Johnson administration in the past year, having been appointed in August.
At Tuesday's City Hall briefing, Johnson said he did not understand why his credibility was being questioned. "I don't even really know why there's a question around trust, to be perfectly frank with you," he said. "If I'm just being perfectly honest, it's actually quite triggering."
He described Gabrysch's departure as a poor fit. "I wish her well, okay? And this clearly was not the right fit," Johnson said.
The dispute centers on how much of the mayor's plan to close an $882 million budget shortfall relies on structural fixes rather than one-time measures. In his budget address last month, Johnson said 76% of his proposals were structural. Days later, Gabrysch told aldermen at the council's first budget hearing that only 56% qualified, arguing that borrowing the mayor sought to cover police misconduct settlements should be counted as a one-time fix, not a structural change.
Sitting beside City Comptroller and Acting CFO Michael Belsky, Johnson said the difference came down to interpretation of a technical budget provision. "There was a different interpretation of a very technical aspect of this budget, and in full transparency and making sure that what was raised in our conversation could be elevated and delivered, we provided both scenarios," he said.
Belsky pointed to the city's annual audited financial reports, known as Annual Comprehensive Financial Reports, as evidence of sound reporting. "I sign this. The mayor signs this. We wouldn't put our signatures on this if it weren't accurate," he said.
Twelve aldermen have signed onto an ordinance calling for a full review of city finances going back three years, to determine whether any material or intentional misstatements were made to investors, the City Council or the public in any document, presentation, offering or financial report.
The measure would authorize Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd), who chairs the City Council Finance Committee, to use her committee's budget to hire an outside firm empowered to request data and records from any city employee. Employees who fail to cooperate could face suspension or firing. The firm would report directly to Dowell, not to the mayor or any other city department.
Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36th) backed the call for a comprehensive audit. "We want to talk about that. Who are some of the folks that were asking her to fudge the numbers?" he said.
Johnson said he welcomes scrutiny. "As I said before, I welcome any audit or investigation. We welcome all of it," he said. "Again, as I've said before, there's nothing surreptitious about our delivery, and it's all codified right here the last three years."
The full City Council is expected to vote Wednesday on the audit proposal. Because it was introduced after the last council meeting and has not been assigned to a committee, aldermen would need 34 votes to suspend the rules and pass it immediately.
The timing is tight: the council and mayor must approve a 2027 budget by the end of the year, and the fallout from Gabrysch's resignation could stretch for weeks or months. For residents and investors alike, the fight raises questions about how transparently City Hall is accounting for its finances at a moment when the city is asking taxpayers to absorb painful budget decisions.