Monday, November 16, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Politics

Aldermen Push Independent Review of Chicago's Finances After CFO's Abrupt Exit

A City Council coalition led by Finance Chair Pat Dowell is moving to authorize an outside review of Chicago's financial reporting, following the resignation of CFO Ashlee Gabrysch, who says she was sidelined for contradicting Mayor Brandon Johnson's budget claims.

Aldermen Push Independent Review of Chicago's Finances After CFO's Abrupt Exit

A coalition of Chicago aldermen is moving to authorize an independent review of the city's finances, aiming to restore confidence among Wall Street rating agencies and the public after the sudden resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch.

The ordinance, championed by Finance Committee Chair Pat Dowell (3rd) and 11 colleagues, would empower Dowell to hire one or more outside professional services firms to conduct an "impartial and comprehensive review" of whether any "material or intentional misstatements of the city's financial condition" were made to investors, the City Council, or the public over the past three years.

City officials and employees would be required to cooperate with the investigation and provide access to all requested records, reports, and information. The ordinance states that anyone who refuses could face "employment sanctions, including suspension or discharge."

"In the wake of last week's resignation of the city's third CFO in a year, we find ourselves at a moment where every effort must be made to secure the public's confidence in our city's finances," Dowell said in a statement.

Gabrysch, a former analyst at Fitch Ratings, stepped down Friday after only three months on the job. She is the third person to serve as Mayor Brandon Johnson's chief financial officer in the past year.

According to sources close to her, Gabrysch quit after being admonished, frozen out, and bullied for publicly and privately disputing the mayor's claim that his $17.6 billion budget was 76% structurally balanced. Gabrysch said only 56% of the measures used to close an $882 million shortfall were truly structural, arguing that settlements tied to police abuse allegations—and the $480 million in borrowing Johnson ordered to cover them—should not be counted as structural fixes.

In an interview Monday, Gabrysch welcomed the outside review, even though it is likely to take months and rating agencies tend to focus more on the city's annual audit.

"Chicago has a history of making things look a lot better than they are… We come out with these billion dollar deficits and, somehow, we make them disappear. Residents don't take it seriously because it really just seems kind of performative rather than actual budgetary strife," she said.

"If this makes it easier for residents to see that Chicago actually is in a fairly dire fiscal situation where hard decisions… and shared sacrifices have to be made, that can be helpful… Shining some light on the city's finances—whether or not they discover wrongdoing, but rather showing the nuances of how dire some things have become—could be worthwhile."

Gabrysch also accused the Johnson administration of what she called "an attempt to smear me and a pretty pathetic attempt at that." Asked whether she would file a defamation lawsuit, she said, "That is a conversation I'm having with my attorneys."

The mayor's office has said Gabrysch was "largely absent during critical periods of the budget preparation process" and has asked Inspector General David Glockner to investigate her decision to direct the city treasurer to forward a $75 million up-front payment from Stonepeak Partners, the New York investment firm that acquired Chicago's parking meters, "without proper legal authority or following the required processes."

Gabrysch countered that the only meetings she missed during budget preparation were to attend conferences approved by Chief of Staff Cristina Pacione-Zayas. She said the $75 million payment was sent to pension funds only after a veto-proof majority of the City Council authorized it, the mayor signed the ordinance, and top mayoral aides were informed.

"I'm not a litigious person, [but] it was very hurtful when that came out. I understand what they were trying to do. But I do think that once the letters are [made public] I will be vindicated. The letters will show that this was not done behind anyone's back," she said. "Twenty-plus people knew this was happening. If there was a true concern about this money being directed, 20 different people could have raised this issue before the money was released."

She added that she stands by her decisions, despite the pushback. "The city of Chicago's CFO needs to be able to speak truthfully to residents, to rating agencies, to the City Council... There should be no political spin of that whatsoever," she said. "I am not one that is easily bullied. I was certainly told what I could and could not say… When I testified in front of City Council, I said a number of things I was told I could not say. They were not happy with me. I was supposed to report to the mayor and I never met with the mayor one on one ever… I certainly was frozen out from different meetings. They went around me. They pulled me from press conferences that I was initially invited to. They went to my staff rather than me on things that should have gone through me."

The mayor's office said it "welcomes any independent audit conducted in accordance with municipal finance standards." It noted that a consortium of accounting firms approved by the Finance Committee already produces the city's Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, and that Chicago has "consistently received strong marks for the accuracy and completeness of its financial reporting."

Civic Federation President Joe Ferguson said there is "nothing that indicates that there are actual fluffing of numbers anywhere," but he still sees value in an outside review, which could be handled by Glockner, a former regional chief of enforcement for the Securities and Exchange Commission.

"There is no trust right now in the administration with the City Council and probably with the markets, so some form of neutral party examination should be done," Ferguson said. "But that is, at best, a months-long project and we have seven weeks to land a balanced budget. As long as it's not a distraction, fine. But nobody should expect any miracles from this alone."

The first fallout from Gabrysch's resignation appeared at Monday's Finance Committee meeting, when a proposed $500 million bond issue for sewer projects was pulled from the agenda at the Johnson administration's request. The move prevented Acting Chief Financial Officer Michael Belsky from testifying and potentially facing questions about Gabrysch's departure.

More from The Chicago Focal