Monday, November 16, 2026·Focal News

The Chicago Focal

Chicago's independent voice

Politics

Federal Prosecutors in Collapsed 'Broadview Six' Case Won't Invoke Fifth Amendment, But Privilege Fight Looms

Three rank-and-file federal prosecutors have told a judge they won't refuse to answer questions about the failed Operation Midway Blitz case, but the Justice Department is still fighting to limit testimony from U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and others ahead of a rare Dec. 2 hearing that could lead to sanctions or criminal contempt.

Federal Prosecutors in Collapsed 'Broadview Six' Case Won't Invoke Fifth Amendment, But Privilege Fight Looms

CHICAGO — Three federal prosecutors who worked on the failed "Broadview Six" case will not invoke their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination when they testify next month, their attorneys told a federal judge Monday, even as the Justice Department continues to assert broad privileges that could sharply limit what the court hears about the prosecution's collapse.

The assurances came during a 20-minute status hearing before U.S. District Judge April Perry, who has ordered U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and Assistant U.S. Attorneys William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez to testify on Dec. 2 about the government's handling of the conspiracy case against six Operation Midway Blitz protesters. The case fell apart in May amid allegations of prosecutorial misconduct.

Attorneys for Hogan, Skiba and Almendarez said their clients do not plan to assert any privileges. Shelly Kulwin, an attorney for Hogan, told the judge his client "doesn't intend to assert any privileges." It remains unclear whether Boutros, the top federal prosecutor in Chicago, will follow suit.

The hearing drew Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the Justice Department's third-highest-ranking official, to the Chicago courtroom — a sign of how seriously the department is treating the matter. In a motion filed late Sunday, Woodward said the four prosecutors have been "instructed" to assert legal privileges, arguing there is "plainly no need for anyone but the U.S. attorney to provide information" and suggesting Perry leave the question to the executive branch, meaning President Donald Trump and Attorney General Todd Blanche. Woodward also floated the possibility of seeking relief from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Perry has said her "sole focus, at this point, is on lack of candor, concealment of material facts, or other misconduct that occurred before me." She has specifically raised questions about claims prosecutors made to her while the case was pending. The Dec. 2 hearing could result in sanctions or even a finding of criminal contempt — an extraordinary outcome for federal prosecutors.

During Monday's hearing, Perry assured the lawyers she would not ask questions "that would call for a privileged answer," but acknowledged the prosecutors might want to offer explanations that cross that boundary. She gave them until Friday to submit a written version of any such testimony for her review, and set a Nov. 25 deadline for the Justice Department to explain why privilege should prevent the testimony from going forward.

Woodward told the judge he was concerned about privileged information being handed to her before the hearing, saying the department "may have an issue" with what he described as the judge "wearing dual hats." Perry responded that it is not unusual for a judge to disregard inadmissible evidence that has come before her.

The case began as a conspiracy prosecution against six protesters involved in Operation Midway Blitz, an immigration enforcement operation that drew widespread demonstrations. The charges collapsed in May after grand jury transcripts and other materials raised questions about the government's conduct. Some of the former defendants watched Monday's proceedings from the courtroom gallery.

The spectacle of federal prosecutors facing potential contempt findings — and having to weigh whether to invoke the Fifth Amendment — has drawn attention far beyond Chicago, raising questions about accountability inside the Justice Department and the independence of federal prosecutions. For local communities that mobilized against Operation Midway Blitz, the hearing represents a rare opportunity to force the government to explain its actions under oath.

Perry's courtroom has already become an unusual venue for scrutinizing the government's own lawyers. The judge has pressed for answers about the accuracy of representations made to her during the case, and the Dec. 2 hearing is expected to test how far courts can go in policing prosecutorial conduct.

Whether Boutros testifies — and what he says — remains the central unknown. The Justice Department's push to limit testimony to the U.S. attorney alone, while shielding rank-and-file prosecutors behind privilege claims, sets up a potential constitutional clash over the separation of powers and the judiciary's authority to investigate misconduct in its own proceedings.

More from The Chicago Focal