Politics
Chicago's Budget Math Divides Mayor and Departing CFO as Council Weighs Outside Audit
Mayor Brandon Johnson insists Chicago's finances are sound and its budget plan is 76% structurally balanced, while his former CFO says the figure is closer to 56%. With a budget deadline looming and a council vote on an outside audit set for Wednesday, the dispute has escalated into a test of public trust.
Mayor Brandon Johnson on Tuesday defended the accuracy of Chicago's financial picture and pushed back on the concerns raised by his departing chief financial officer, framing the dispute as a difference in interpretation rather than a crisis of confidence.
"I wish her well, and this clearly was not the right fit," Johnson said of former CFO Ashlee Gabrysch during a press briefing.
Gabrysch resigned Friday after roughly three months on the job, releasing a public statement saying that remaining in the role "would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations." She was the third CFO to leave the administration this year.
At the center of the disagreement is how much of next year's budget plan rests on recurring revenue rather than one-time fixes. Johnson said he considers the plan 76% structural. Gabrysch publicly put the figure at 56%, arguing that borrowing to cover police misconduct settlements should not count as structural revenue.
Acting CFO Michael Belsky joined the mayor in vouching for the accuracy of the city's numbers.
Joe Ferguson, president of the Civic Federation, a nonpartisan research organization, said the gap reflects two different frames on the same document.
"She did it from her technical, financial industry expertise lens and language. The administration is doing it from their political narrative. We shouldn't be shocked about that. We do need to have answers," Ferguson said.
Half a dozen City Council members are now calling for an investigation. The council is scheduled to vote Wednesday on an ordinance that would authorize an outside firm to examine the city's finances.
"The fact that she abruptly quit and was concerned about the direction that she was given should give everybody pause, and that's why we want to move forward with this investigation," said Ald. Gilbert Villegas of the 36th Ward.
Johnson said he has nothing to hide. "I welcome any audit or investigation. We welcome all of it. Again, as I've said before, there's nothing surreptitious about our delivery," he said.
The political stakes are immediate. More than half the council currently opposes the mayor's budget plan, and the body has until the end of the year to pass a spending plan or risk a government shutdown.
"Job one right now is to land a balanced budget, and we're very, very far away from that, with not much more than six weeks left," Ferguson said.
For Chicago residents, the dispute carries direct consequences: the credibility of the numbers behind city services, the cost of police misconduct settlements, and whether the budget relies on sustainable revenue or accounting maneuvers that push problems into future years. The Wednesday vote on an outside review will signal whether the council intends to settle that question before or after the budget deadline.