Local
Chicago’s fall housing lull may give buyers more room to negotiate
October has historically brought lower sale prices and more negotiating leverage in Chicago, but rising mortgage rates and limited listings continue to strain affordability. Buyers may face less competition this fall, though a seasonal discount is no guarantee of a cheaper monthly payment.
Chicago homebuyers may find more room to negotiate in October, when seasonal demand typically eases and sellers whose properties have lingered on the market may be more open to price cuts or other concessions. But higher home prices, scarce inventory and rising mortgage rates are keeping many buyers on the sidelines.
A September report from Redfin identified October as one of the better months to seek a deal in Chicago and 15 other major U.S. cities. The company’s analysis defines the seasonal opportunity by when discounts from original asking prices — through reductions or negotiation — tend to be largest.
Chicago’s fall market is quieter than the spring and summer rush. Tommy Choi, a Keller Williams One Chicago agent, said a Lincoln Park townhome he recently listed drew four offers and fewer than 30 visitors. The home still sold for nearly $100,000 above its asking price, but Choi said it likely would have attracted stronger competition during the summer.
Historical data point to a seasonal price difference. Illinois Realtors found that from 2021 through 2025, Chicago’s median sale price in October averaged 10% below June’s, generally the busiest month for home purchases. Homes also tend to spend longer on the market in fall, which can strengthen a buyer’s negotiating position.
That seasonal pattern does not mean prices are low. Redfin data put the Chicago metro area’s median sale price at $366,500 in October 2025, up about 33% from October 2020. In June, the median rose from $269,000 in 2020 to $407,000 in 2025, an increase of roughly 51%.
Mortgage costs add another hurdle. Freddie Mac reported an average 30-year fixed mortgage rate of 7.40% in the week cited by the report, compared with 6.27% a year earlier. National pending home sales fell 4% from August in September and were down 8.6% from the year before. Chicago pending sales dropped 5.8% year over year, while 14.1% of deals under contract fell through, according to Redfin.
Redfin Chief Economist Daryl Fairweather said sellers who have not secured offers by October may be more willing to negotiate as they try to complete a sale before the holidays. But higher borrowing costs have also pushed some prospective buyers out of the market.
The local market remains shaped by a shortage of homes for sale. Ezekiel Morris, managing broker of EXIT Strategy Realty/EMA Management, said buyers he serves on the South Side have sometimes widened their searches beyond the North Side. Down-payment assistance programs can also help some qualified buyers stretch their budgets, he said.
Dan Gjeldum, executive vice president of mortgage lending at CrossCountry Mortgage, said rate increases have led some prospective clients to pause and prompted him to revisit payment estimates with pre-approved borrowers. He attributed some of the pressure to inflation and higher oil prices, among other factors.
For buyers still able to afford a purchase, agents and lending professionals said the end of the year can offer opportunities, but urged them to weigh the full monthly payment and their own finances rather than assume rates will fall or prices will drop. Choi said fall prices may compare favorably with peak-season levels, while Gjeldum advised buyers to review payment scenarios with a mortgage professional before adjusting their budget.