Local
Chicago Renters Face Unpredictable Utility Bills as Landlords Adopt Ratio Billing
A growing number of Chicago landlords are shifting volatile gas and water costs onto tenants through ratio utility billing systems, leaving renters with unpredictable monthly bills and little legal recourse. Tenant unions and consumer advocates are pushing back, but state and city regulations lag behind the practice.
When Maiko Lehman moved into her Edgewater apartment in 2022, her utility costs were predictable: a flat $100 monthly fee covering gas, water and trash, clearly stated in her lease. Then the building changed hands in 2024, and management switched to a ratio utility billing system, or RUBS, outsourcing the billing to a third-party company called Conservice.
Since then, Lehman's monthly utility bills have swung from $88.05 to $225.57. She has repeatedly asked property management to explain the formula used to divide the building's master utility bills among tenants, but has gotten no answers. Her building's manager, Berkshire Residential, did not respond to requests for comment.
"It was a known fee," Lehman, 56, said of her old arrangement. "It was in the lease, and you knew it when you moved in."
Lehman is among tens of thousands of Chicago renters in master-metered buildingsâproperties without individual gas and water metersâwho are now billed through RUBS. The system divides the building's total utility costs among units based on factors such as square footage and occupancy, then adds a service fee. Consumer advocates say the practice is spreading rapidly as utility costs climb and billing companies aggressively market their services to landlords.
"RUBS basically shifts risk of volatile, rising utility costs off of the landlords and onto the tenants," said Olivia Wein, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center. "There are now many RUBS companies developing these products for landlords. At the same time, people are experiencing unaffordabilityâthe cost of everything is going up."
Neither Chicago's Department of Buildings nor the Department of Housing tracks how many buildings use the practice. Illinois has no law banning RUBS, and no agency regulates the billing companies. The Illinois Commerce Commission, which oversees utilities, said in a statement that it "does not have authority over ratio metering. This would be a tenant-landlord matter."
State law does require landlords to notify tenants before switching to RUBS and gives renters the right to see master utility bills. Mayor Brandon Johnson's Protecting Renters Ordinance, currently before the City Council, would codify some of those same protections. But Wein said existing rules don't go far enough, creating "an opportunity for abuses to proliferate" because of the lack of transparency and a clear regulator.
Landlord groups defend the practice. The Illinois Apartment Association said in a statement that RUBS "provides an accurate estimate based on actual usage" and that a "fair, transparent, and consistent RUBS formula promotes resident conservation, encourages responsible utility usage, and creates management efficiencies that reduce upward pressure on rent." The Neighborhood Building Owners Alliance said only about 10% of its members use RUBS.
But tenant advocates dispute that the bills reflect individual usage. Wein noted that tenants who leave town for weeks sometimes return to higher bills. "The tenant's bill is not tied to actual tenant usage," she said.
In South Shore, 85-year-old Viola Davis has become a leader in the fight against the practice. For years she paid a flat $105 utility fee on top of rent for her one-bedroom at Oglesby Towers. Since early this year, when landlord Stuart Handler and TLC Management switched the building to RUBS, her utility costs have ranged from about $150 to more than $220 a month. Some neighbors have seen bills as high as $500, she said.
Davis, who lives on her pension and Social Security, said the uncertainty has forced her to make difficult choices about groceries and gifts for her great-grandson. She and her neighbors contacted the community organizing nonprofit Southside Together and formed a tenant union. After their first news conference in August and a letter demanding a meeting with management, the landlord reversed a trash fee, according to housing organizer Savannah Brown. The group continues to push for an end to RUBS.
"RUBS is essentially a variable rent increase," Brown said. "This is just another thing to push out folks who have been in the neighborhood for the longest, who have been in this building for decades."
At a second news conference last month, 63-year-old resident Antoinette Gray said she was being evicted because she could not keep up with the bills. "When Stuart Handler started RUBS, it had a real impact on me, my life, everything," Gray said. "I've done the best I could to stay here. Their response has been, 'If you can't pay, just leave.'"
Handler and TLC Management did not respond to requests for comment. Conservice also did not answer questions about its billing services; its Better Business Bureau page has drawn more than 150 reviews averaging one out of five stars.
Wein said the safest way to protect housing affordability is to prohibit the practice outright. Some jurisdictions have taken that step: Connecticut has banned RUBS, and Seattle and Los Angeles are considering similar measures. "It is very hard to craft a comprehensive consumer protection law when it comes to RUBS," Wein said, adding that the practice could drive more evictions nationwide.
For Lehman, the uncertainty remains a monthly burden. She worries about neighbors on limited incomes who are struggling to keep up. "There's people in the building now who are flirting with whether they can afford the rent, and all of a sudden, this month the bill is higher for the utilities," she said.