Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Boston Focal

Boston's independent voice

Local

Massachusetts High Court to Review Lindsay Clancy's Double Jeopardy Appeal as Jury Notes Reveal 11-1 Acquittal Split

The Supreme Judicial Court will hear oral arguments in January 2027 on whether to dismiss murder charges against Lindsay Clancy, whose first trial ended in a mistrial after jurors voted 11-1 to acquit and accused the holdout of refusing to deliberate in good faith.

Massachusetts High Court to Review Lindsay Clancy's Double Jeopardy Appeal as Jury Notes Reveal 11-1 Acquittal Split

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will hear oral arguments in January 2027 on whether to dismiss the murder case against Lindsay Clancy, the Duxbury mother whose first trial ended in a hung jury, after a single justice on Thursday granted full-court review of her double jeopardy claim.

Associate Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar wrote that after weighing the defense petition, the Commonwealth's opposition, and the trial court's Nov. 9 order, the court concluded that review by the full bench is warranted. The defense brief is due Dec. 3, the Commonwealth's brief Dec. 17, and any reply from the defense Dec. 28.

The appeal turns on newly public handwritten notes from jurors in the first trial, which ended in a mistrial. The notes show the panel voted 11-1 in favor of acquittal and that jurors accused the lone holdout of failing to deliberate in good faith.

One note asked: "A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?" Another stated: "The juror has made statements, acknowledging doubt, but refused to apply that to the verdict."

Clancy's lawyers argue that Judge William Sullivan should have questioned the foreperson and the holdout juror to determine whether there was cause to remove that juror. Because he did not, they contend, the mistrial was avoidable and a second trial would violate the constitutional protection against double jeopardy.

Sullivan denied the defense's motion to dismiss on Nov. 9. The two sides returned to court this week, when the judge set a date for a second trial and prosecutors indicated they would again seek a first-degree murder conviction before a jury. The defense then appealed to the Supreme Judicial Court on Monday.

The case has drawn intense attention in Duxbury and across the region, raising difficult questions about mental health, the limits of the justice system's response to illness, and how courts handle jurors who resist the consensus of their peers. The release of the jury notes offers the public an unusually direct view of the closed-door deliberations that produced the mistrial.

The high court's decision to take up the petition means the second trial will not proceed on schedule while the justices weigh whether the charges must be dismissed outright. A ruling is expected after oral arguments in January 2027.

More from The Boston Focal