Local
Judge Keeps 'Turtleboy' Blogger Aidan Kearney Free on Bail, Tightens Rules After Livestream of Witness Texts
A Boston judge declined to jail Aidan Kearney over alleged bail violations but barred him from broadcasting any impounded or court-protected material, warning 'no mistakes.' His witness-intimidation trial was pushed to February 2027.
A Suffolk Superior Court judge on Thursday refused prosecutors' request to lock up blogger Aidan Kearney before trial, instead tightening the conditions of his release after allegations that he read a witness's text messages aloud during an online livestream.
Kearney, who publishes under the name "Turtleboy," was charged in 2023 with nine counts of witness intimidation stemming from his extensive coverage of the Karen Read murder case. He has pleaded not guilty and argues his reporting is protected by the First Amendment.
Prosecutors returned to court this month alleging Kearney violated his bail by reading text messages from Jennifer McCabe's cell phone during one of his livestreams. McCabe, a key witness in both of Read's trials, received the messages through the discovery process, and prosecutors said Kearney had been warned not to disseminate them.
In a court filing, prosecutors argued that a simple reminder would be meaningless. "Telling the defendant that from now on he must obey the orders of the court which he has already enthusiastically and knowingly defied obviously will not suffice," they wrote, urging the judge to revoke his release or impose "a sanction with suitable teeth."
Judge Christopher Belezos declined to revoke bail but rewrote the terms of Kearney's release. "Any material which is impounded or protected by this court is not to be broadcast, rebroadcast, published, addressed in any public forum by Mr. Kearney," the judge said. "Are we clear on this? No mistakes."
Kearney's defense lawyer countered that the messages he read on air were already publicly available.
The ruling is not the first time prosecutors have sought to detain Kearney. In April, a Suffolk Superior Court judge warned him he was "walking on kind of thin ice."
Kearney's trial, originally scheduled to begin in December, has been postponed to Feb. 1, 2027, because of a scheduling conflict with another trial before the same judge.
The case is intertwined with the Read saga, which has drawn national attention. Read was tried on charges connected to the death of her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O'Keefe; her defense contended that McCabe played a central role in framing her. McCabe and other trial witnesses have also filed a defamation lawsuit against Kearney and Read.
For local observers, Thursday's hearing underscores the tension between the broad latitude courts give online commentators and the limits judges can impose when reporting collides with protected evidence. Kearney remains free â but under a narrower set of rules, with a trial date now roughly two months away.