Local
Former Stoughton Deputy Chief Tied to Birchmore Case Retains $56K Annual Pension Despite Decertification
Robert Devine, a former Stoughton police deputy chief whose certification was revoked over misconduct related to Sandra Birchmore, remains eligible for an annual retirement benefit of $56,544 under Massachusetts law. The revelation comes as another former Stoughton officer, Matthew Farwell, awaits sentencing after a federal jury convicted him of killing Birchmore.
A former Stoughton Police Department deputy chief whose state certification was revoked in connection with the Sandra Birchmore case is still positioned to collect a substantial annual pension, according to public records filed with the Norfolk County Retirement System.
Robert Devine, who retired in 2022 amid allegations that he and two other officers had an inappropriate relationship with Birchmore, is eligible for an annual retirement benefit of $56,544, the filing shows. The figure was first reported Monday.
The pension eligibility persists even though the Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission, known as the POST Commission, decertified Devine last year. The commission cited what it described as a pattern of unprofessional police conduct that may escalate, specifically referencing his relationship with Birchmore.
Under Massachusetts law, Devine remains entitled to his retirement benefits unless he is criminally convicted. He has not been charged in connection with Birchmore's death and has denied the allegations against him. During a hearing before the POST Commission, he claimed Birchmore lied about everything. He is currently appealing the commission's decision.
Birchmore was 23 years old and pregnant when she was found dead in her Canton apartment in 2021. Her death was initially ruled a suicide, but federal investigators opened a probe after Stoughton police disclosed an internal investigation.
The case has since produced a federal conviction. Last week, a jury found former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell guilty of killing a witness or victim and of violating a federal law protecting unborn children in the deaths of Birchmore and her unborn child. Prosecutors presented evidence that Farwell began a sexual relationship with Birchmore when she was 15 and a member of the Stoughton Police Youth Explorers program, which he helped run. Farwell is expected to seek a new trial.
The pension arrangement for Devine highlights a gap in state oversight: decertification by the POST Commission does not automatically strip an officer of retirement benefits earned through municipal service. Only a criminal conviction triggers forfeiture under current statute.
For residents of Stoughton and the wider region, the case has raised pointed questions about accountability within local police departments and whether administrative penalties are sufficient when misconduct is substantiated. The POST Commission's findings against Devine did not result in criminal charges, leaving his pension intact while his appeal proceeds.
The Norfolk County Retirement System filing does not indicate whether Devine has begun collecting the benefit. Attempts to reach Devine for comment were not immediately successful.