Local
New Federal Rule Could Displace Nearly 1,000 Mixed-Status Families in Massachusetts, Housing Advocates Warn
A HUD rule taking effect Dec. 15 requires every public housing resident to prove citizenship or lawful immigration status, ending a 1995 policy that let mixed-status families live together with prorated rent. Massachusetts advocates say fear of sharing documents with the federal government could push families to self-evict, with roughly 1,000 households potentially affected.
Housing advocates across Massachusetts are warning that a new federal rule requiring every resident of federally subsidized public housing to prove U.S. citizenship or lawful immigration status could force families apart and deepen the state's affordable housing crisis.
The rule, issued last Thursday by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, takes effect Dec. 15. Tenants must submit proof of eligible status by March 14. It ends a policy in place since 1995 that allowed mixed-status families â households where some members are citizens or lawful residents and others are not â to live together in HUD-assisted housing. Under that arrangement, the government subsidized only eligible family members, and households paid a higher, prorated share of rent.
The new requirement eliminates that option. Advocates say families would have to choose between staying together outside public housing or splitting up so eligible members can keep their assistance.
"They are going to be separated, or they have to self-evict," said Zafiro Patiño, director of organizing for the Massachusetts Union of Public Housing Tenants. "That's what we are hearing mainly â that people are going to be afraid of actually revealing these documents, and they are going to self-evict."
Patiño said the fear is especially acute in immigrant communities during the Trump administration's broader immigration enforcement push. Even family members with legal status may hesitate to hand documents to federal agencies, she said.
The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a nonpartisan research institute, estimates that nearly 1,000 households in Massachusetts would be affected â the fourth-highest total in the country, behind California, New York and Texas. More than 180,000 Massachusetts households receive federal housing assistance and would be subject to the verification requirement.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner has said the rule is meant to ensure that only citizens and eligible immigrants benefit from federally subsidized housing, pointing to long waiting lists.
"It's unacceptable that America's homeless veterans, disabled, elderly, and victims of domestic violence languish on waitlists while illegals and ineligibles scam our system," Turner said in a statement. "American taxpayers will no longer foot the bill. Promises made, promises kept."
The agency said an audit with the Department of Homeland Security found nearly 200,000 tenants with incomplete or unknown eligibility verification.
The administration tried to impose similar requirements in 2019 and revived the proposal this past February. In April, a coalition of 22 state attorneys general, including Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Campbell, sent a letter to HUD opposing the change.
Patiño also questioned whether the administration has weighed the financial and administrative costs of enforcing the rule. She noted that U.S. citizens in mixed-status households could lose assistance if they cannot obtain or submit the required documents before recertification deadlines.
"So many actually American citizens, they are going to be affected because they are not going to be able to recertificate on time and bring those documents," she said.
Rey Santana, president of the Mystic Tenants Association in Somerville, said the policy would add pressure to a shelter and affordable housing system already stretched thin.
"How would they get into these programs when they're already so overflown with people who have already been there?" Santana said.
With housing costs already straining many Massachusetts residents, Santana warned that pushing more people out of public housing would ripple outward.
"Even if you're not directly affected, you're still affected by this change," he said.