Local
Seattle Residents File Class-Action Claim Over Alleged 'Phantom Garbage' Fees
Four Seattle residents have filed a class-action claim against the city, alleging they were repeatedly charged for extra garbage and yard waste they never set out. The claim targets the city's reliance on contractor reports from Recology and Waste Management, which critics say lack independent verification.
Four Seattle residents have filed a class-action claim against the City of Seattle, alleging they were repeatedly billed for extra garbage and yard waste they never put outâcharges that collectively may have cost ratepayers millions of dollars.
The claim, filed by attorney Andrew Ackley, argues that the city's reporting and review system for extra-waste fees does not adequately verify reports from its waste contractors, Recology and Waste Management. Ackley told local media that his clients were charged hundreds of dollars over several years, often in increments of $7.50 or $14.
"The way to solve a systemic problem is not to put the burden on every single consumer to dispute every seven or $14 charge," Ackley said.
The allegations echo findings from a 2022 City Auditor report, which found that Seattle Public Utilities (SPU) charged customers $9 million in extra-waste fees in 2020. That report also noted that SPU planned to analyze whether there were racial or other disparities in how those charges were assessed.
More recently, the city's latest solid-waste audit, published in September, examined commercial billing. Auditors found that SPU did not review whether extra charges on commercial bills were appropriate or examine contractors' extra-waste reports. SPU disagreed with the recommendation to monitor those charges, citing cost and staffing constraints, and said it planned to continue relying on commercial customers to flag erroneous charges.
Council President Joy Hollingsworth, who chairs the City Council committee overseeing SPU, referred questions to the utility. SPU declined to comment. Waste Management and Recology did not respond to requests for comment.
The claim raises questions about accountability and equity in a city that has prioritized waste reduction and climate goals. With millions of dollars in extra-waste fees collected annually, the case could have broad implications for how the city oversees its private waste contractors and protects residents from erroneous charges.