Local
King County and Snoqualmie Tribe Split Tokul Trail Network in $10.4M Land Deal
King County bought 475 acres of Tokul West for $6.75 million, preserving at least six miles of trails, while the Snoqualmie Tribe acquired 602 acres of Tokul East for $3.65 million and closed its trails to the public. The deals mark the county's largest land acquisition in two decades but leave the future of seven trail miles uncertain.
King County and the Snoqualmie Tribe have each purchased portions of the Tokul trail network outside Fall City, a 17-mile multiuse system popular with mountain bikers and horseback riders, in a multimillion-dollar transaction that ranks as the county's largest land acquisition in 20 years.
The county announced Monday it had bought Parcel B, 475 acres known as Tokul West, for $6.75 million. The Snoqualmie Tribe purchased Parcels C and D, 602 acres known as Tokul East, for a combined $3.65 million, according to documents recorded with King County on Oct. 30 and Nov. 4.
The seller was Portland-based J.P. Morgan Natural Capital, formerly Campbell Global, which put more than 4,000 acres of timberland up for auction in June. The portfolio was divided into four parcels; three have now sold. Parcel A, at 3,745 acres the largest piece, was listed at $33.7 million and remains unsold.
The split outcome preserves at least six miles of trails for public access on Tokul West, now without a recreation fee. Another seven miles of trail in tribal ownership have been closed to the public, with red-and-white "No Trespassing" and "Posted Private Property" signs posted last week where the Lower Midtown, PNWheel and East Climb trails intersect with the Snoqualmie Valley Trail. The tribe declined to comment on future plans for the Tokul East network.
King County Executive Girmay Zahilay called the Tokul West purchase a "generational achievement for land conservation" as the county pursues a goal of preserving 65,000 acres of open space within 30 years.
"This is a culturally important area to the Tribe and is a sensitive area within the Snoqualmie River Watershed," Snoqualmie Tribal Chairperson Robert de los Angeles said. "We encourage all visitors to recreate with respect when visiting Snoqualmie Ancestral Lands."
The Tokul trails are prized for south-facing slopes that drain quickly in winter and for their proximity to the Fall City Horse Arena. Local mountain bikers built the first informal trails in the 1990s when Weyerhaeuser owned the land; later owners formalized access in 2012 with a recreation permit that charged $15 per day or $82 per year.
When the auction was announced, riders pressed Metropolitan King County Council Chair Sarah Perry, who conveyed the urgency to the Department of Natural Resources and Parks. "I was very clear that we absolutely want this land because the community use of it was so strong," Perry said.
Auctions required the county to move faster than its usual land-acquisition process, which typically involves identifying willing sellers and applying to the independent Conservation Futures Advisory Committee for money collected by the Conservation Futures Tax. That timeline can exceed a year; here the county had about three months.
The Tokul property borders the Snoqualmie Valley Trail and had been on the county's radar since it tried to buy the parcels in the early 2000s. The county prioritized Tokul West because a buyer could have built up to 30 homes there. The parcel was appraised at $4.85 million, according to Perry, and the county justified its nearly $2 million higher bid by calculating recreational and ecological value.
At first the $6.75 million bid appeared to fall short. The county learned Aug. 11 it had not won the auction, then was asked Sept. 9 whether it would resubmit. John Rosenthal, president of Realty Marketing/Northwest, which oversaw the auction, declined to comment on the initial winning bid and why it fell through, as did a spokesperson for J.P. Morgan Natural Capital.
Sam Jarrett, the parks department's Open Space Program lead, said the money came from projects at a standstill, so no other planned acquisition was delayed or canceled. The county also used funding from the King County Parks Levy, which voters reapproved last year.
The purchase will generate new conservation revenue through a transfer of development rights program: the potential home development on Tokul West will be extinguished by a conservation easement and the right to build sold to developers who can build higher in urban areas. The current market value of those development rights is $1.5 million, according to Interim Parks Director Mo McBroom.
Jarrett said six miles of trails will remain open on Tokul West, while the future of additional trails crossing into J.P. Morgan Natural Capital's remaining holdings will require negotiation with the landowner. Access to 15 named trails, including popular intermediate routes Bobsled, DIY and Pink Beaver and expert trail Tokyo Drift, will be unchanged.
Public ownership also gives the informal trails official standing. "A ragtag group of people devoted to Tokul have been maintaining the trails over the years, so with us now being county land, it allows opportunities for organized maintenance," said Holly Sato, a Fall City resident who administers the Facebook group Tokuls Only.
Groups such as the Evergreen Mountain Bike Alliance, which could not work on the land under private ownership, can now lend expertise for signage, mapping and possibly future trail builds. "We're interested in seeing the recreational access to these lands maintained to the greatest extent possible," McBroom said.
Sato said the trail community is of two minds. "The county owning the land will help to protect access to recreation and will hopefully allow for future trail development opportunities," she said. "While we are obviously disappointed to lose access to Tokul East, I'm happy the tribe has ownership over their ancestral land and would welcome any future conversation about Tokul East."
Perry said the tribe's declared interest in Tokul East led the county to avoid bidding for it, even though those parcels offered more acreage for roughly $3 million less while preserving about the same mileage of trail. "If they have an interest in reclaiming a particular area, we're not going up against the tribe," she said. "We respect the tribe as a sovereign nation, and we want to continue to work together in a non-adversarial way."
The Snoqualmie Tribe has documented concerns about recreation's effects on ancestral lands. A 2022 tribal document, "Recreation Impacts on Snoqualmie Tribe Ancestral Lands," notes that outdoor recreation can harm resources essential to tribes and cites studies finding elk have a 65% chance of fleeing when a mountain biker comes within just under a mile.
Longtime trail builder Peter Sherrill, who acted as a liaison between mountain bikers and Campbell Global, said the closure did not surprise him. He pointed to the Tulalip Tribes' closure of trails near county-owned Moss Lake after a November 2024 purchase of 18,000 acres, and to the state Department of Natural Resources' October decommissioning of four community-built mountain bike trails on Rattlesnake Mountain, known as the Exit 27 trails, partly due to tribal pressure.
Trail advocates are not giving up on Tokul East. On Nov. 22, horseback riders plan a Rally to Save Our Trails, open to bikes as well, in hopes of maintaining access to both sides of the network.