Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Seattle Focal

Seattle's independent voice

Local

Four Seattle Residents File Class-Action Claims Over 'Extra' Garbage Fees

Four Seattle residents have filed tort claims alleging the city has knowingly collected millions in inaccurate 'extra garbage' fees, the first step toward a proposed class-action lawsuit. The claims target Seattle Public Utilities' billing practices and contracts with Recology and Waste Management.

Four Seattle Residents File Class-Action Claims Over 'Extra' Garbage Fees

Four Seattle residents have filed tort claims against the city, alleging that Seattle Public Utilities has for years collected millions of dollars in inaccurate "extra garbage" fees while knowing the charges were flawed. The claims, filed this week, are the first step toward a proposed class-action lawsuit.

The residents—Elizabeth Forsyth, Patti Gorman, Karen Deyerle and Hugh Rubin—are represented by Stritmatter Law. They seek reimbursement for what they call "unfair and unlawful charges" and want the city to ensure accurate billing going forward.

At issue is a $13.95 fee the city charges each time its contracted garbage collectors document "extra garbage"—trash propped against a bin or overflowing from the top. Seattle Public Utilities levied the fee more than 342,000 times last year, sometimes for multiple bags, generating about $8.7 million.

The claims allege the city has known its collectors inaccurately report these fees and that its contracts with solid waste haulers Recology and Waste Management indirectly incentivize overreporting. Under the contracts, collectors are paid a bonus for each percentage point above 95% accuracy and docked for each point below 85%. But the claims say the city's monitoring system only checks whether collectors report extra garbage that city inspectors also found—not whether they report extra garbage that isn't there.

"The City only audited to make sure that the contractors were reporting extra waste," the claims state. "It did not audit to make sure the contractors accurately reported the absence of extra waste."

Andrew Ackley, a lawyer for the claimants, said that under this system, collectors could conceivably report and bill for extra garbage at every house they stop at and still be audited at 100% accuracy, because they would match every instance city inspectors found.

The claims also argue that Seattle Public Utilities obscures the charges by bundling them with water and sewer bills, which vary monthly, and by placing them on the last page of a three-page bill after a boilerplate page of phone numbers. Customers can call 206-684-3000 to dispute a charge, but the claims say the city will only remove charges going back two billing cycles.

"The City uses data it knows to be inaccurate a significant percentage of time, obscures extra solid waste charges from customers, and has implemented an unreasonably tedious and ineffective dispute process for customers who notice inaccurate charges," the claims say.

Forsyth was previously featured in reporting last spring after discovering years of what she believed were bogus extra garbage fees on her utility bill. "I am happy to pay for garbage that I set out, or if someone is illegally dumping on my property, that's my responsibility, too," Forsyth said in April. "If you've got a photo of it, I am happy to pay for it, but I believe these are fraud."

Both Seattle Public Utilities and the city's office of finance, which receives tort claims, declined to comment Wednesday.

The claims follow earlier reporting on the city's extra garbage fee practices. The proposed class action would cover Seattle Public Utilities customers who were charged the fees.

More from The Seattle Focal