Politics
Lurie, Mahmood Revive Transfer Tax Cut for Big Real Estate Sales, Citing Housing Crisis
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood are pushing a revised plan to cut San Francisco's transfer tax on real estate sales over $10 million, aiming to spur housing construction. The proposal includes new exemptions for new construction and large development projects, and comes after voters rejected a competing measure that would have locked in the higher tax rates.
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood announced Thursday they are resurrecting a plan to reduce San Francisco's transfer tax on large real estate transactions, hoping to jumpstart housing development that has stalled amid high construction costs and financing challenges.
The revised proposal would tax transfers of properties valued between $10 million and $25 million at 3.5%, down from the current 5.5%. Sales of $25 million or more would be taxed at 4%, down from 6%. The cuts are slightly less generous than an earlier version introduced in February, which proposed rates of 2.75% and 3%, respectively.
Mahmood said he now has the votes to pass the measure at the Board of Supervisors and expects approval before the end of the year.
The city currently has nearly 88,000 housing units that are planned but not under construction. Developers say they cannot secure financing to break ground, and that the transfer tax makes it harder because investors who front money need a sufficient profit margin when the building is sold to justify the risk.
âBuilders tell us that the current 6% transfer tax is the single biggest barrier to new housing thatâs within the cityâs control,â said Corey Smith, executive director of the Housing Action Coalition, a housing industry advocacy group.
The new version adds provisions not included in the original proposal. The first sale of a newly constructed building with three or more housing units would be entirely exempt from the transfer tax. Additionally, âdevelopment agreementâ projectsâlarge complexes like the planned developments at Treasure Island and Stonestownâwould be exempt during early construction phases, when the primary developer often sells portions of the project to other builders.
Building new housing in San Francisco currently costs between $700,000 and $1,200,000 per unit. The city estimates the tax cut would reduce developer costs by about $60,000 per unit.
Lurie framed the tax cut as part of his housing affordability agenda. âToday we are moving forward on the BUILD Act to make it easier to build the homes our city needs,â he said.
The proposal follows the defeat of Proposition I, a ballot measure placed by the Democratic Socialists of America and others that would have locked in the higher transfer tax rates on large real estate sales and directed the revenue to affordable housing. It also would have barred the Board of Supervisors from lowering the tax without a vote of the people.
Lurie strongly opposed Prop. I, joining the firefighters and police unions in warning that it would âcarve a massive, permanent hole in the cityâs general fundâthe same fund that pays the firefighters, paramedics, and police officers who respond when San Franciscans call 911.â He spearheaded a $2.8 million campaign against the measure, largely funded by real estate interests. It lost 52% to 48%.
Lurie and Mahmood argue the new tax cut will not create the same budget problem because voters also passed Proposition J this November, which requires properties in foreclosure to pay the transfer tax. The city controller estimates Prop. J will generate $100 million to $150 million annuallyâroughly the amount the tax cut is expected to cost. However, the controller also found that revenue from Prop. J would likely âdecline significantly over time.â
âOur labor and housing partners told us revenue neutrality was essential, and we took that seriously. This version reflects their feedback,â Mahmood said.
Supporters of Prop. I, who anticipated the tax cut would be revived if their measure failed, are unlikely to be satisfied. Earlier this year, they expressed frustration that the cut would apply not only to new housing but also to commercial real estate and older apartment buildings, even though taxing those properties does not affect housing development.
âRents are going through the roof, but building flippers really need a tax cut,â said Dan Raile, a DSA member and volunteer leader on the Prop. I campaign. âTrillions of dollars are about to flood into the tightest real estate market in the country and the response from City Hall is to give corporate landlords a tax break.â