Local
Supes Weigh Moving Hall of Justice Downtown After Decades of Seismic Warnings
San Francisco Supervisor Matt Dorsey wants to relocate the seismically unsafe Hall of Justice, which has been flagged as a hazard since 1992 and was rated high-risk in 2017. The proposal comes as rainwater poured through the building's ceilings during recent storms.
San Francisco Supervisor Matt Dorsey is pushing to move the city's criminal courthouse out of the seismically unsound Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St., arguing that the building has been a known hazard for more than three decades.
Dorsey made the case during a meeting of the Board of Supervisors' Budget and Finance Committee on Wednesday, the same day that rainwater from a major storm leaked through the building's ceilings.
"The Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St. has been called a seismic hazard since the Agnos administration," Dorsey said at the hearing. "But more than three decades later, the building is still standing."
The building has been deemed unsafe to inhabit since 1992. In 2017, the Judicial Council of California gave it a "high-risk" seismic rating, meaning it is unlikely to withstand a major earthquake. That same year, sewage leaked through the ceiling of the district attorney's office, prompting the DA to relocate.
The DA's office was one of six departments that have left the building since 2008. The last jail facility in the courthouse closed in 2020.
Despite the building's condition, thousands of defendants, plaintiffs, attorneys, judges, and law enforcement officials continue to use the facility each year.
The proposal to relocate the courthouse downtown raises questions about the future of the 850 Bryant St. site and the cost of building a new facility. It also comes as city officials grapple with competing budget priorities and a push to make public buildings more resilient to climate-driven extreme weather.
Dorsey's push to move the courthouse follows years of warnings from seismic experts and repeated disruptions from the building's failing infrastructure. The supervisor's office did not immediately provide details on a timeline or potential locations for a new courthouse.