Local
South Bay Attorneys Demand ICE Stop Courthouse Enforcement After Public Defender Pepper-Sprayed
The La Raza Lawyers Association is calling for an end to ICE operations near San Jose's Hall of Justice after a deputy public defender was pepper-sprayed while recording an arrest, raising fears that immigrants and crime victims will stop showing up to court.
SAN JOSE â A coalition of South Bay prosecutors, public defenders and private attorneys is demanding that federal immigration agents stop operating around the Santa Clara County Hall of Justice and the adjacent Main Jail, warning that enforcement near the courthouse is undermining the justice system itself.
The La Raza Lawyers Association, a prominent attorneys' group in Santa Clara County, made the call Thursday, days after a deputy public defender was pepper-sprayed by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents while recording an arrest just steps from the courthouse.
"The way that they framed the Constitution, everyone has access to justice, everyone has a right to due process," association President Felipe Romero said.
The incident that galvanized the group unfolded last week. Deputy Public Defender David Oyer said he happened to be walking by when ICE agents moved to detain a man near the Hall of Justice. Oyer began recording the arrest on video. Footage of the encounter shows agents then pepper-spraying Oyer.
"I am OK," Oyer said. "A little shaken up mentally, but physically OK."
Oyer has filed a police report alleging the agents assaulted him. But he said the damage goes beyond the physical: he worries the agents also assaulted the criminal justice system. Some of his clients have told him they are now too frightened to appear in court.
"That's certainly something I worry about," Oyer said. "It's something I've heard from clients. I'd imagine it's happening as well with the victims and witnesses of crimes."
Romero echoed that concern, saying the chilling effect could ripple through cases across the county.
"It could be potentially pretty detrimental in terms of prosecuting cases, but more specifically, it's detrimental to the community because then they can't seek that justice," Romero said.
The Department of Homeland Security, in a statement about the pepper-spray incident, said the man agents were detaining had a history of drug possession and delivering drug paraphernalia. The agency said roughly eight "agitators" obstructed the agents' path and that officers used their training to de-escalate after the group began physically assaulting them.
The confrontation has intensified a broader debate over immigration enforcement at courthouses, where victims, witnesses and defendants often must appear regardless of their immigration status. Legal advocates have long argued that arrests at or near courthouses deter people from cooperating with prosecutors and reporting crimes, effectively allowing offenses to go unpunished.
For Santa Clara County's legal community, the pepper-spraying of a public defender in the course of his work has turned that abstract concern into a concrete confrontation â and a test of whether the courthouse remains a place where everyone can safely seek justice.