Local
SF Supervisors Weigh Data Center Moratorium Extension as Grid Nears Capacity
A new Planning Department report warns San Francisco's power grid is close to its limit even before any new data centers are built, as supervisors prepare to vote Tuesday on extending a 45-day moratorium by 10.5 months.
San Francisco's electricity transmission system is approaching its maximum capacity even without any new data centers coming online, according to a Planning Department report that lands as the Board of Supervisors prepares to decide whether to extend a temporary ban on the facilities.
The city imposed a 45-day moratorium on new data centers last month and commissioned the Planning Department to compile initial findings and policy options for city leaders. That moratorium expires at the end of November, and the board is scheduled to vote Tuesday on whether to extend it for another 10 and a half months. Nine of the 11 supervisors would need to back the extension for it to pass.
The report's most striking conclusion is that San Francisco is nearing the upper limit of its power grid capacity regardless of whether new data centers are approved, raising questions about whether the city can absorb the electricity-intensive facilities without putting housing production and other priorities at risk.
The analysis also found that existing data centers are concentrated in Bayview-Hunters Point, a neighborhood that already carries a disproportionate share of environmental burdens and elevated air pollution. That finding is likely to sharpen the debate over siting and cumulative impacts as supervisors weigh the extension.
The moratorium vote comes amid heightened attention to the land and lobbying behind proposed projects. In August, top City Hall officials discussed a large parcel at 1215 Michigan St. in Dogpatch with a lobbyist representing a private equity firm interested in bringing a new data center to the city, according to reporting on the site.
Supporters of a longer pause argue the city needs time to understand the grid constraints and environmental consequences before committing power capacity to server farms. Critics of an extended moratorium contend that a lengthy freeze could chill investment and that the city can manage demand through planning and infrastructure upgrades.
The Planning Department's report is intended to give supervisors a factual foundation for that choice, pairing its capacity findings with a set of policy recommendations. With the current moratorium set to lapse at month's end, Tuesday's vote will determine whether San Francisco keeps the door closed on new data centers into next year or begins accepting applications under whatever rules the board ultimately adopts.