Local
SF Public Defender Mano Raju Fights $26,000 Contempt Fine in Appeals Court, Calls for More Funding
San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju appeared before California's 1st District Court of Appeal on Thursday to challenge a $26,000 contempt fine for refusing to accept all felony cases, arguing his office is overwhelmed by caseloads and underfunded. Public defenders from 36 California counties issued a joint statement supporting him, and the court is expected to rule within 90 days.
San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju went before California's 1st District Court of Appeal on Thursday to contest a contempt ruling and a $26,000 fine imposed after he refused to accept some felony cases assigned to his office, arguing that crushing workloads and inadequate funding made it impossible to provide effective representation.
The fine stems from a May 2025 decision by Raju to stop accepting every case assigned by the court. San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman later held the office in contempt for 26 separate acts, ordering a $1,000 penalty for each, and ruled that the Public Defender's Office did have enough attorneys to handle the assigned caseload. The fine has been stayed pending the outcome of the appeal.
In oral arguments Thursday, Raju's legal counsel, Kory DeClark, cited a California Penal Code statute that requires the state to provide alternative counsel when the Public Defender's Office is unavailable. DeClark also argued that the lower court failed to collect sufficient data about the office's caseload before determining it had adequate staffing.
Speaking to reporters after the hearing, Raju called for increased funding for public defense. "If we are going to have a society that chooses to arrest and prosecute this many people, then we have to fund public defense," Raju said. "Otherwise, you have people waiting, as I said before, for weeks, months, or years for their day in court. You have wrongful convictions that can happen. You have people being separated from their families, and it doesn't just impact the people that we're representing."
The day before the hearing, public defenders from 36 California countiesâincluding Alameda, Marin, Santa Cruz, Santa Clara, Contra Costa, Napa, Solano, Mendocino and Montereyâissued a joint statement in support of Raju.
The dispute comes amid a broader surge in felony cases brought by the District Attorney's Office, which has strained court resources and prompted audits and the release of some defendants. Raju has argued that his office, which is legally mandated to represent clients who cannot afford counsel, has been stretched thin by rising caseloads and flat funding.
The 1st District Court of Appeal is expected to issue a ruling within the next 90 days. The outcome could set a precedent for how public defender offices across California handle excessive workloads and whether courts must provide alternative counsel when defender offices are unable to take on new cases.