Local
San Francisco Extends Data Center Moratorium for 10 Months and 15 Days
San Francisco supervisors unanimously extended a moratorium on new data centers for another 10 months and 15 days, citing the need to study environmental impacts. The pause affects proposed facilities in Dogpatch and Centre Mall and halts an expansion at 400 Paul Ave. in Bayview, a neighborhood already burdened by industrial pollution.
San Francisco supervisors voted unanimously on Tuesday to extend a moratorium on new data center construction for an additional 10 months and 15 days, giving the city more time to assess the environmental and community impacts of the facilities. Supervisor Connie Chan was absent from the meeting.
The extension follows a 45-day moratorium introduced in October by District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton, which also passed without opposition. The legislation applies to facilities of all sizes that house digital information or computer systems.
A planning department analysis recommended several policy changes before new data centers are approved, including banning standalone data centers in residential or commercial areas, updating the city's 2001-era definition of data centers to align with the state's, and requiring facilities to assess their impact on surrounding communities.
The report noted that data centers offer opportunities to support the city's digital infrastructure but also present challenges. Larger facilities "can also place significant demands on electricity systems, generate air quality and noise impacts from backup power equipment, and raise questions about the use of limited land and infrastructure," the report said.
The assessment examined the city's three standalone facilities but acknowledged it does not maintain a complete inventory of smaller data centers housed within office buildings. According to Data Center Map, there are 15 potential data centers in San Francisco, including smaller facilities incorporated into other buildings, many located downtown.
Two standalone, larger data centers at 200 Paul Ave. and 320-400 Paul Ave. are located in Bayview's industrial hub. The southeastern neighborhood has for decades experienced disproportionate air pollution compared to the rest of the city due to industrial operations, truck traffic, and a former PG&E power plant that closed in 2006.
NOVVA, an existing data center at 400 Paul Ave. in Bayview, had been scheduled to expand from nine to 36 megawatts by 2028. Those plans are now on hold.
Two other potential data centersâone in Dogpatch and another in the now-closed Centre Mallâhave been proposed or eyed by developers in the past year.
Walton, who represents Bayview, said the city needs to "know what these impacts are" and how they affect the neighborhood's residents. "Until that happens," he said, "It needs to stop."