Local
Lurie, Mahmood Revive BUILD Act to Slash Transfer Taxes on Big Real Estate Deals, Aiming to Kick-Start Stalled Housing
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood are reintroducing legislation to cut San Francisco's transfer tax on large property transactions, arguing it will unlock tens of thousands of stalled housing units. The revived BUILD Act, now paired with recently passed Proposition J, is pitched as revenue-neutral, but tenant advocates call it a giveaway to corporate landlords.
San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood are resurrecting a controversial plan to cut the city's transfer tax on large real estate transactions, hoping to jump-start construction of tens of thousands of housing units that have been stalled by high costs and a sluggish market.
The legislation, known as the BUILD Act, was first introduced in February but was shelved a week after the June election, with insiders pointing to the city's budget deficit and fears that reducing transfer tax revenue would deepen the fiscal hole. The city has budgeted about $360 million in transfer tax revenue for the current fiscal year, according to a June report from the controller's office.
Now, following this month's passage of Proposition Jâa measure sponsored by Lurie and Mahmood that closes a loophole allowing lenders to avoid transfer taxes on foreclosed propertiesâthe pair are bringing the bill back. Mahmood said the new version is more balanced, emphasizing that revenue from the loophole closure is expected to fully offset the rate reductions, leaving the city's finances unchanged.
"The primary objective is to help new housing construction break ground, because the transfer tax rate that we have is higher than any other major city in the country," Mahmood said, adding that the legislation will bring San Francisco's tax structure closer to that of other large cities.
The proposal would partially unwind a 2020 voter-approved measure that doubled the transfer tax on sales of $10 million or more. Because a 2024 ballot measure gave the Board of Supervisors the power to lower the tax without returning to voters, Lurie and Mahmood can enact the cut through legislation rather than another election.
Under the revived plan, the tax rate on property transfers valued between $10 million and $25 million would fall from 5.5% to 3.5%, and the rate on sales of $25 million or more would drop from 6% to 4%. Both rates would remain above pre-2020 levels of 2.75% and 3%, while rates for single-family homes would stay unchanged. The cuts are intended to make new or vacant buildings financially feasible to reactivate or build.
For multifamily housing, the bill goes further: the first transfer of newly constructed or converted multifamily buildings with three or more units would be exempt from the tax. Large projects operating under development agreementsâcontracts between the city and developers that lock in rules and require public benefitsâwould also be exempt during early infrastructure construction, easing site preparation on complex developments with large workforces.
Housing advocates praised the revived push. Corey Smith, executive director of the Housing Action Coalition, said eliminating the transfer tax on multifamily housing developments is "one of the fastest ways to get approved projects off the sidelines and into construction."
"We're taxing new homes in San Francisco as if we had a surplus, not a shortage," Smith said in a statement. "We've learned from Los Angeles that taxing new construction heavily costs cities both homes and revenue."
But tenant advocates sharply criticized the proposal as a giveaway to corporate real estate interests amid rising housing costs. Shanti Singh, legislative and communications director with Tenants Together, tied the announcement to the same day as the Anthropic IPO.
"Daniel Lurie looked at corporate landlords hiking rents up 25% and decided the fix to our acute rental emergency is to announce a corporate landlord tax break on the day of the Anthropic IPO," Singh said. "It beggars belief how out of touch he is with how much people are hurting right now."
In a statement, Lurie said the bill will "unlock stalled housing projects across our city, continue the revitalization of downtown, create thousands of jobs, and help lay the foundation for a stronger, more vibrant San Francisco."
"San Francisco should be a place where people can put down roots, and today we are moving forward on the BUILD Act to make it easier to build the homes our city needs," he added.
Mahmood expects the legislation to pass the Board of Supervisors next month. The debate over the transfer tax has long divided City Hall, with progressives seeking higher rates to fund city services and moderates pushing for cuts to spur housing construction. The revived BUILD Act will test whether a revenue-neutral compromise can satisfy both sidesâor reignite a familiar fight.