Local
Concord's New Immigration Judge Has History of Excessive Force Allegations, No Asylum Grants in 65 Cases
Michael Rapiejko, a former police officer accused of excessive force in Arizona and New York, began hearing Concord immigration cases in July and has yet to grant asylum in 65 decisions. His hiring is part of a Justice Department push to recruit 'deportation judges' with little immigration law experience.
CONCORD â One of the newest immigration judges assigned to the Concord Immigration Court is a former police officer who faced allegations of excessive force in two states and who, since taking the bench in July, has not granted asylum in any of the 65 cases he has heard, according to court data.
Michael Rapiejko, 45, hears cases remotely from a detention center complex in Florence, Arizona. Before his appointment, he worked for one year as an attorney for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, following most of a legal career spent in tax law, including seven years at the Internal Revenue Service. He graduated from Quinnipiac University School of Law in 2018.
Rapiejko is among hundreds of recent hires brought in to replace immigration judges fired by the Department of Justice over the past two years. Many of the new judges have limited experience in immigration law, according to a review of 257 judges' biographies. The hiring wave followed a Justice Department advertising campaign this spring that solicited "deportation judges" with salaries ranging from $159,951 to $207,500.
Immigration judge positions do not require prior experience in immigration law. Candidates must hold a law degree, an active bar license, and at least seven years of legal practice. Rapiejko meets those requirements and is an active member of the District of Columbia Bar.
His background as a police officer has drawn scrutiny. In 2005, while working for the New York Police Department, Rapiejko arrested a man who later sued him, alleging that Rapiejko pointed a gun at him, ordered him back into his car, and choked him. Court records show Rapiejko's lawyer acknowledged the gun was drawn and the order given but denied the choking allegation. The city settled the lawsuit for $20,000.
A decade later, while an officer in Marana, Arizona, dashcam video captured Rapiejko driving his cruiser over a curb and into an armed suspect who had threatened to kill himself. He was placed on administrative leave for three days, and the department's internal review board cleared him of wrongdoing, finding his use of force "appropriate, reasonable and timely." A civil lawsuit filed by the suspect was dismissed in 2016.
The Executive Office for Immigration Review, which oversees the immigration court system, declined to comment on Rapiejko's background or qualifications, citing a policy against discussing personnel matters. Rapiejko did not respond to multiple requests for comment made through the courts where he works.
Rapiejko's asylum grant rate of zero in 65 cases aligns with the low rates at the Concord court during the same period, which are far below the 32% nationwide approval rate in the year before the Trump administration took office in 2025.
Maddie Boyd, an attorney with an immigration nonprofit, said Rapiejko's appointment is another example "of the administration prioritizing fast-tracked deportation over a system that is neutral."
Jeremiah Johnson, vice president of the National Association of Immigration Judges and a former San Francisco immigration judge, said hiring and background standards have weakened under the current administration.
"The process is not as robust as it used to be, and that is concerning because of how important the job is," Johnson said.
Rapiejko is not the only new judge with a law enforcement background. Brett Rogers, now an immigration judge in West Los Angeles, spent 18 years with the Seattle Police Department and was placed on administrative leave in 2002 after a fatal shooting of a man brandishing a sword; he was later cleared of wrongdoing. Other new Concord judges include Ryan Beyers, who had one year of ICE experience, and Lucas Abbott, who had four months.