Sunday, November 22, 2026·Focal News

The San Francisco Focal

San Francisco's independent voice

Local

California's Expanded Conservatorship Law Yields Modest Gains, Data Shows

Three years after Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 43 to broaden involuntary treatment for severe mental illness and addiction, data from the state's largest counties shows conservatorship numbers have barely budged, leaving families and advocates questioning whether the law can deliver on its promise.

California's Expanded Conservatorship Law Yields Modest Gains, Data Shows

SACRAMENTO — When Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 43 in 2023, families of people living with severe mental illness and addiction hoped the expanded conservatorship law would finally compel their loved ones into treatment. Disability rights advocates warned of forced medication and lost autonomy. County officials braced for a surge in referrals.

Three years later, that surge has not materialized. Data obtained from California's 25 most populous counties shows that in most of them, the number of people under one-year mental health conservatorships has barely changed since the law took effect.

Of the 19 counties that provided point-in-time data, 12 reported increases of less than 5% or outright decreases in their conservatorship caseloads. On average, counties saw an increase of less than 6%, and the overall number of cases across the analyzed counties rose by just 4%.

"It was not at all as big an impact as we thought it could be," said Toni Navarro, director of behavioral health for Santa Barbara County, where conservatorships have dropped 1% since the law took effect there in July 2025.

SB 43 broadened the nearly 60-year-old Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, which defines when someone is so "gravely disabled" that they cannot care for themselves. Previously, the standard meant a person could not provide food, clothing or shelter due to severe mental illness or chronic alcoholism. The new law adds inability to provide for one's safety or medical care, as well as incapacity due to severe substance use disorder.

Counties were allowed to delay implementation until January of this year, and many did. Some experts say the law's real effect may not be apparent for years.

Only three counties reported using the new law to conserve anyone solely because of a substance use disorder — a total of six people statewide. Most counties are not tracking whether people are conserved under the law's other expanded criteria.

Some counties did see larger increases in short-term 72-hour psychiatric holds, known as 5150s. San Mateo County's short-term holds rose by more than a quarter in the six months after the law took effect compared with the prior six months. Los Angeles County wrote more than 500 such holds for severe substance use disorder between January and June 2026. But those holds often do not lead to lasting treatment, and people frequently cycle between hospitals and the street.

County behavioral health directors say the law's structure is partly to blame. The first step toward involuntary care is a 72-hour psychiatric hold. If someone is held because of drug use, they typically regain the ability to care for themselves once the drugs wear off — and then no longer qualify for a conservatorship.

"We can't ignore that there isn't a tremendous amount of evidence to support this treatment model," said Michelle Cabrera, executive director of the County Behavioral Health Directors Association, citing research suggesting forced addiction treatment can reduce drug tolerance and increase overdose risk after release.

Still, officials say the law has produced some benefits. Including substance use in conservatorship criteria has forced mental health and addiction treatment departments — often siloed — to collaborate more closely. About 60% of patients with serious mental illness in Orange County's behavioral health system also have a substance use disorder, according to Kelley, the county's behavioral health director.

"We've been trying to merge those systems, because it's the same brain, for decades," Kelley said.

For some families, the law's shortcomings are deeply personal. Annis Pereyra, whose son Joaquin Anthony "Tony" Pereyra was shot and killed by Walnut Creek police in February during a mental health crisis, believes the new law could have saved his life if Contra Costa County had used it to compel him to take clozapine, an antipsychotic that had previously stabilized him for 15 years.

"His needs were ignored at every turn that happened. Every single turn," Pereyra said. "He wasn't put on the only medication that saved him from the horrors of his illness."

Tony Pereyra was diagnosed with schizophrenia after his first psychotic break in high school. He had held a job and lived independently while on clozapine, but stopped taking the medication in 2024 after his mother experienced a medical emergency. In March 2025, he violently attacked his parents. He was placed in locked facilities under a temporary conservatorship but released without resuming clozapine, his mother said. The county's attempt to reach him through CARE Court also failed.

Contra Costa County has seen one-year conservatorships increase by 13% since the law took effect — from 98 cases to 111 — more than many other counties. The county's behavioral health department declined to make anyone available for an interview.

At an October vigil outside the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors chambers in Martinez, about 40 people gathered to honor Tony Pereyra's memory. Gigi Crowder, chief executive of the local NAMI affiliate, told the group she was tired of getting calls that police had shot and killed another person with mental illness.

"This was a totally avoidable death," Crowder said.

Board Chair Diane Burgis stood quietly to the side. "Sometimes, sitting up at the dais, people can get the impression that we don't care," she later said. "I just wanted to be with those folks because I understand that experience. I share their frustrations."

During public comment, Annis Pereyra approached the microphone wearing a button with her son's picture. She described the bullet tearing through his chest and the cold asphalt where he died.

"Treatment before tragedy works," she said. Her two minutes expired before she could read her final line: "Implement SB 43 to the fullest extent possible to save others."

Sen. Roger Niello, a Roseville Republican and one of the law's 23 co-authors, said society's reluctance to overrule civil rights and compel treatment is hampering the law's effectiveness, but added that it is too early to judge. The bigger obstacle, he said, is funding.

"First we need funding," Niello said. "If we're not going to have funding, if we're not going to increase the capacity for treatment, then I'm not sure there's any amount of time that would show success."

The law's author, former Sen. Susan Talamantes Eggman, a Stockton Democrat, did not respond to multiple interview requests.

The modest results come amid broader frustration with the Newsom administration's mental health initiatives. A CalMatters investigation found the governor's signature CARE Court program has helped fewer people than anticipated, and a recent bond measure has seen all projects slated to open last year delayed or canceled.

"It's scary, the gaps are scary," said Teresa Pasquini, a longtime mental health advocate whose son lives with mental illness.

More from The San Francisco Focal